'Elderly people sitting on chairs for hours and hours': As CUH staffing row rumbles on, patients suffer
By August, CUH was recording a 56.1% increase in patients on trolleys in the ED at 8am every morning. Picture: Noel Sweeney staff
Daragh McGann is one of thousands of patients who rely regularly on Cork University Hospital, so was not surprised to hear staff shortages making the news.
The spotlight shone on the issue in August when the hospital's chief executive Jennifer Kearney raised concerns with HSE management about shortages and recruitment. Things have now escalated with Taoiseach Micheál Martin to meet those involved on Monday.
Darragh McGann, from Cobh, lives with multiple sclerosis (MS).
Describing visits to the busy ED, Mr McGann said: “What I was observing wasn’t fine, a lot of elderly people sitting on chairs in these little pods, for hours and hours and hours.”
Waiting 11 hours once last winter the singer met people waiting twice that for a bed after being admitted.
“Things have changed, the MS nurse specialists that were in CUH forever and a day have retired and the new people are not as accessible to patients.
“You can only contact that department now Monday to Thursday from 9am to 12 noon, and after that take your chances somewhere else.”
Read More
Letters sent by Jennifer Kearney to her regional manager for Cork and Kerry and later to national HSE chief executive Anne O’ Connor refer to a shortfall of about 1,000 staff.
A particular concern is how new financial restrictions slow down hiring.
Since June, all six HSE regions must have hires sanctioned by Ms O’Connor. In addition, since September, sanction from the Department of Health is required for four regions, including HSE South West.
Ms O’Connor’s approval is needed for non-pay spending above €5,000, and the department must approve spending on external consultancy firms such as PWC.
In August, health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill said the ask for more staff was “unrealistic”.
Just weeks later, she was in Cork to open the surgical hub and it is understood she had a private conversation with Ms Kearney then.
Minutes of a meeting in late August involving Ms Kearney and HSE South West regional executive manager Dr Andy Philips, reported on this month, show a testy exchange.
He has since apologised for incorrectly claiming to have been instructed by the offices of the Taoiseach and health minister “to have some very specific conversations with you”.
This was after a recording emerged. The act of recording then became the political issue.
CUH clinical directors wrote to Mr Martin last month. The consultants’ committee chair Dr Greg Fulton has said his colleagues support Ms Kearney and called for an independent assessment of staff numbers.
Liam Conway from the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation said its members in CUH stand by the chief executive and her concerns.
So when Ms O'Connor told the Oireachtas committee she has not spoken to Ms Kearney and criticised CUH for “conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity” it did not land well.
She was pressed by TDs and senators on whether she had “full confidence” in Dr Philips.
She said she has confidence in him — but declined to say she has “full confidence” and did not respond to questions as to whether his position is tenable.
When she pushed back on sharing granular CUH staffing detail from the HSE payroll, calls persisted for a workforce assessment other than the patient safety inspection done by Hiqa on November 5 and 6.
Its report is not yet finalised, Hiqa said this week.
Ms O’Connor also noted an internal process in HSE South West, which she said was being led by Kevin Foley, former Labour Court chairman. This followed concerns raised internally by managers in HSE South West last year. A HSE spokesman said after the hearing: “There is currently a process under way to support resolution and it would not be appropriate to comment further on it at this point."
There was some surprise at the intensity of questioning, but with CUH also taking patients from Munster and parts of south Leinster for specialist care, as well as Cork and Kerry, pressure is growing on Government.
It is the only Model 4 hospital with adult, child and maternity care on a single campus, for example. Patients come from as far as Laois for cancer care.
Doctors this week spoke up, encouraging patients to keep coming, but people like Darragh McGann are worried especially if they need an ambulance over the coming winter.
By August, CUH was recording a 56.1% increase in patients on trolleys in the ED at 8am every morning.
It is so short of beds the HSE has committed to opening 341 more beds there, but unions argue without staff then beds are just furniture.
Other hospitals are also seeing pressures, with management from HSE Mid West meeting politicians last month to discuss similar fears.
This is while flu numbers are still low, with just 87 people around the country in hospital with the virus last week.
From Ms Carroll MacNeill’s viewpoint, the problem is the spiralling health budget.
In 2020, this was set for €17bn and rose sharply during the pandemic, now standing at €29bn.
She has spoken of her shock at realising the medicines budget is twice the State’s defence budget.
This week she insisted in the Dail: “There is no recruitment embargo in the HSE. This year we had provision to hire 3,300 people contingent on a reduction in agency, we've hired 4,000 people... we've gone way beyond the additionality.”
When University Hospital Limerick reached crisis point, the then health minister Stephen Donnelly sanctioned a review of emergency care across the whole Mid-West region.
People will be watching this week to see if Ms Carroll MacNeill or indeed the Taoiseach takes any radical action on concerns raised in another part of Munster.




