Over half of Cork TDs support external independent review of CUH staff numbers

One TD said there appears to be a 'personality clash' between HSE and CUH management
While no TD rejected the idea of an independent assessment of staffing levels at Cork University Hospital, many Fianna Fáil TDs said they wanted to see the outcome of a Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) report before looking to an external examination. File picture: Dan Linehan

While no TD rejected the idea of an independent assessment of staffing levels at Cork University Hospital, many Fianna Fáil TDs said they wanted to see the outcome of a Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) report before looking to an external examination. File picture: Dan Linehan

Over half of Cork’s TDs have backed an external independent assessment of staffing levels at Cork University Hospital amid calls for a mediator to be appointed to resolve the bitter “personal” disputes between the hospital and the HSE.

Noel McCarthy, Fine Gael TD for Cork East, said there appears to be a “personality clash” between HSE and CUH management, and relationships need to be repaired before the hospital’s issues can be resolved.

While no TD rejected the idea of an independent assessment, many Fianna Fáil TDs said they wanted to see the outcome of a Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) report before looking to an external examination.

It comes ahead of a crunch meeting between Taoiseach Micheál Martin and CUH CEO Jennifer Kearney and other management officials next Monday.

Up to Friday evening it remained unclear if the health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill will accompany the Taoiseach to the meeting despite her sustained criticism of CUH. The Department of health declined to say if she would attend.

Instead a spokesman said the minister met patient safety experts on Friday, including chief medical officer Professor Mary Horgan and HSE's Dr Colm Henry.

The Minister is waiting on a report from Hiqa on CUH , the spokesperson added.

The Irish Examiner has contacted all 20 TDs across the five Cork constituencies in recent days to ask if they are in favour of the external assessment of staffing sought by CUH.

Out of 20 TDs contacted by this newspaper, 11 of the 19 who responded backed an external assessment of staffing. This included Fine Gael’s Cork North-Central TD Colm Burke, who said any assessment should focus on the hospital’s most affected areas.

“There are key areas in the hospital where this could be done immediately, as there is clear evidence that there has been a substantial increase in numbers requiring additional staff,” he said.

“A full review from an external appointee would take too long. Yes, it could be done, but we need to immediately prioritise the key area where there are insufficient staff.”

Mr McCarthy said that to fix the problems at CUH, the relationship between senior management in the HSE and CUH needed to be fixed first. “I think a mediator needs to sit them down and sort that problem out with them,” he said.

'Faith in Hiqa’s ability'

Pádraig O’Sullivan, Fianna Fáil TD for Cork North Central, said there are “clearly problems” at CUH and “whoever diagnoses what the problems are, I don't think it would matter if you're internal or external”.

Aindrias Moynihan, Fianna Fáil TD for Cork North-West, meanwhile, said Hiqa has been at CUH in recent weeks, and there must be “faith in Hiqa’s ability” to assess the situation.

Fine Gael’s John Paul O’Shea, TD for Cork North-West, said Hiqa is an independent body.

James O’Connor, Fianna Fáil TD for Cork East, meanwhile, lambasted HSE CEO Anne O’Connor for failing to engage with Ms Kearney, calling it “appalling” and “inexcusable”. He said the Taoiseach and health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill must order a meeting between the pair.

Seamus McGrath, Fianna Fáil TD for Cork South-Central, said Ms O’Connor must travel to Cork to meet Ms Kearney and the CUH clinical directors next week.

“Assuming this happens and following this engagement, if the clinical directors still believe that an independent assessment is necessary, then I will fully support them,” he added.

Michael Moynihan, a Fianna Fáil junior minister and TD for Cork North-West, called for the HSE and CUH to “get around the table” and resolve the issues.

Jerry Buttimer, a junior minister and Fine Gael TD for Cork South-Central, said there are “clearly challenges” that can be resolved “through constructive engagement”.

The Taoiseach, meanwhile, has repeatedly said Hiqa must be allowed to do its job in assessing CUH. A spokesman referred this newspaper to his Dáil comments.

Opposition backing

All of Cork’s opposition TDs backed an independent assessment. This included Sinn Féin TDs Pat Buckley, Thomas Gould, and Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire, Liam Quaide and Pádraig Rice of the Social Democrats, Labour’s Eoghan Kenny, and Michael Collins and Ken O’Flynn of Independent Ireland.

A Social Democrats spokesperson said Holly Cairns, who is currently on leave ahead of the birth of her second child, would support the position of her Social Democrats colleagues.

Fianna Fáil TD Christopher O’Sullivan did not respond to queries.

  • Louise Burne, political correspondent

More in this section

Politics

Newsletter

From the corridors of power to your inbox ... sign up for your essential weekly political briefing.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited