There is a 'witch hunt' against CUH chief Jennifer Kearney, Dáil told
Ivana Bacik: 'Is the CEO of the HSE suggesting that Jennifer Kearney has done something wrong?'
There is a “witch hunt” against Cork University Hospital (CUH) chief Jennifer Kearney following her repeated concerns about staffing and patient safety, the Dáil heard on Wednesday.
Labour leader Ivana Bacik told the Dáil there was an attempt to “silence” those raising concerns.
Cian O’Callaghan of the Social Democrats, meanwhile, dismissed the idea that CUH was conducting its business through the media, arguing that HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor had not spoken to Ms Kearney about her concerns but had spoken to RTÉ to downplay them.
The Government and the HSE have been at loggerheads with CUH and Ms Kearney in recent months. It follows concerns raised by Ms Kearney that staff numbers at CUH were impacting patient safety and posed greater concerns the closer it got to the winter.
Read More
Health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has argued that CUH has received a greater allocation of staff than any hospital “by some distance” but still has some of the highest trolley numbers.
She also questioned why CUH does not have staff for CT scanners.
Speaking in the Dáil, Ms Bacik questioned if the Government wanted to “silence those who speak out about failings in the health service”.
“Is the CEO of the HSE suggesting that Jennifer Kearney has done something wrong?” she asked Taoiseach Micheál Martin.
“If so, what? This looks like a witch hunt, Taoiseach. Jennifer Kearney has not given media interviews about her letter.
“She used official channels to raise her concerns in the spring and early summer. As the winter drew nearer, having received no substantive response, she wrote the strongly worded letter setting out profound concerns for patient safety.
“Far from being an overreaction or creating a media offensive, she raised these concerns carefully. She was ethically obliged to do so, but she is now being pilloried for it.”

Ms Bacik said that it wasn’t Ms Kearney who inflamed the situation, rather a “HSE regional manager who used false political threats”.
This was in response to Andy Phillips, the regional executive officer of HSE South West, who has apologised for telling Ms Kearney that he had been instructed by the Taoiseach's office to have “very specific conversations with her”.
Mr O’Callaghan said Ms O’Connor went on the radio on Sunday to “lambaste Jennifer Kearney and CUH for conducting its management business via the media”.
“On the one hand, the head of the HSE is on the airwaves attacking CUH for raising serious issues in the media, and at the same time, the head of the HSE doesn't even talk directly to CUH,” he said.
“It takes a lot longer to drive to RTÉ than it takes to pick up the phone. It is an absolutely remarkable admission.”
In response, Mr Martin said he had met with Ms Kearney in October but would have preferred to meet her before she started sending letters that made their way into the media.
He insisted that there is a process in place, which involves HSE chief clinical officer Colm Henry and CUH.
“Hiqa has to be involved, the National Patient Safety Office,” Mr Martin said.
“It just can't be you or I or others saying, ‘I'm putting my hand up and saying, There's a safety issue.
“There has to be a systemic basis, has to be standards and metrics that govern whether there is a safety risk or not. Then there's a separate issue about resources, in terms of advancement, development, and so on like that.”
- Louise Burne, Political Correspondent




