CUH row: Renewed call for independent assessor to review staffing levels
For months, hospital management has been at loggerheads with the HSE and the health minister over staffing levels. Picture: Noel Sweeney
Renewed calls for an independent assessor to review staffing levels at Cork University Hospital have been made amidst the latest in a row between the HSE, the health department and hospital management.
For months, hospital management has been at loggerheads with the HSE and the health minister over staffing levels.
In August, CUH chief executive Jennifer Kearney wrote to senior HSE officials warning of a shortfall of about 1,000 staff, caused by recruitment restrictions and delays in approving posts.
She urgently sought the prioritisation of 172 posts before the busy winter season.
The health minister has repeatedly dismissed concerns around staffing, saying CUH has hired twice as many staff as had been budgeted for, and suggested that CUH was not managing its affairs properly.
Vascular surgeon at the hospital and consultant rep, Dr Greg Fulton, said there is a "difference in opinion" between staffing levels attributed by the HSE and the health department and also by CUH management.
"Our staffing allocation is around 4,900, and currently the staffing is around 5,100. So we are about 200 staff over, give or take," he told on Monday.
"We believe that this figure should be substantially greater by the order of 700-800, even up to 1,000 staff.
"An example we had earlier in the year: between 150 and 200 agency staff were made permanent as part of a directive from the HSE and Department of Health.
"So from one day to the next, there was no change in the staffing, but these people essentially became CUH staff members overnight.
"So the numbers went up by 200 technically, but in fact the ceiling never went up to reflect this," Dr Fulton said.
He claimed that the number of people working at the hospital has stayed the same and is calling on the minister, the CEO and the HSE to appoint an independent assessor to come in and "see what the numbers are."
"Either they are wrong, or Jennifer Kearney is wrong. By bringing somebody in for one day, we will be able to sort this out once and for all," Dr Fulton said.
He added that he could not "really understand" what the chief executive of the HSE, Anne O'Connor, was saying in regard to bringing an assessor in.
"I think she turned around and said it was not necessary; I think that was the expression she used," Dr Fulton said.
"And I think the only reason that she possibly cannot want an independent assessor is because she thinks there's a prospect that her figures are incorrect", he said.
The vascular surgeon added that the claims made by Ms O'Connor of 55 extra doctors and 59 extra nurses were hires "made during the moratorium".
"They weren't subject to the moratorium, but even though they were hired, the ceiling number didn't change, so it's the same problem all the time. The number is incorrect.
"And what we want is an independent assessor to come in and find out exactly what the staff allocation of the hospital should be," Dr Fulton added.




