CUH row: HSE chief accuses hospital of 'conducting its management business via the media'

Anne O'Connor to tell Oireachtas health committee hospital's 'increase in staffing this year is bigger than the combined increase in Beaumont, the Mater, St James and Tallaght University hospitals'
HSE chief executive Anne O'Connor will tell politicians on Wednesday morning that CUH is not alone in facing 'huge service pressures'. File picture

HSE chief executive Anne O'Connor will tell politicians on Wednesday morning that CUH is not alone in facing 'huge service pressures'. File picture

The chief executive of the HSE will this morning reignite the war of words with Cork University Hospital by accusing it of "conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity".

Anne O'Connor will also tell the Oireachtas health committee she will not reiterate all of the investment put into the hospital in recent years "except to say their increase in staffing this year is bigger than the combined increase in Beaumont, the Mater, St James and Tallaght University hospitals".

Her comments are the latest broadside against the hospital in a bitter dispute between HSE senior management, health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill and CUH management, which has been ongoing since August.

It began after CUH chief executive Jennifer Kearney wrote to HSE management warning of a shortfall of 1,000 staff, saying it was caused by recruitment restrictions and delays in approving posts.

This was dismissed by Ms Carroll MacNeill, who pointed out CUH had hired twice as many staff as had been budgeted for and that the hospital was not managing its affairs correctly.

Anne O’Connor will tell politicians on Wednesday morning that CUH is not alone in facing “huge service pressures”.

“But it is unique in that it appears to be conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity,” Ms O’Connor will tell TDs.

Ms O’Connor will say CUH and other hospitals are likely to respond by saying regardless of staffing increases, “they remain under severe pressure”.

“They would be right. CUH and many other hospitals have seen a significant increase in its emergency presentation in recent times,” Ms O’Connor will add.

“However, all hospitals have responsibility to manage their services and provide reassurance to patients while ensuring that the public money provided to them is managed in the most effective way possible for their communities.”

The HSE chief executive will add that as CUH heads into a “difficult winter”, the central HSE will work with them to get through it.

“We need to change the working environment that has been created recently so we can engage respectfully and professionally and work together through the coming months for the benefit of the patients that we serve.”

Ms O’Connor is also expected to warn of the “very serious financial position” faced by the HSE, and she will add the gap between spending and funding has “grown over a number of years”.

She will point to recruitment controls, agency restrictions and expenditure approval thresholds introduced earlier this year, but say spending “continued to outpace the benefit being achieved”.

This required additional spending controls, she will add.

“There are encouraging signs that these measures are influencing performance,” she will say, and will add the six HSE regions have “improved their adherence to expenditure limits”.

Supplementary health budget

It comes as the Government agreed to further bail out the Department of Health, with an €780m supplementary budget confirmed by the Cabinet on Tuesday.

On Tuesday, Mr Martin told the Dáil there had been an “exponential growth” in health spending, adding there was a need for a debate and not just “spend, spend, and spend”.

He was responding to questions from Labour leader Ivana Bacik, who said some staff at CUH were being counted twice in Government statistics in what she described as “gaslighting”.

“At Cork University Hospital, we saw the double counting of staff who moved from agency contracts to HSE contracts. The same people carrying out the same work at the same hospital, but being counted twice for the purpose of fictional staffing figures,” Ms Bacik said.

Mr Martin pointed to the increasing demand for hospital care with a growing population.

“In our hospitals, spending has gone up by about 22%, staffing by 33% since the start of 2020. So there's no argument that there's been very significant increase in spending."

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited