HSE recruitment plans 'unsafe and unworkable', nurses and midwives say
The nurses and midwives letter says the revised employment control processes 'obstruct essential recruitment, undermine our professional judgment, expose patients and staff to foreseeable harm, and threaten our registration'. File picture
Disputes around staffing in health ramped up when 137 senior nurses and midwives told the Government that recruitment plans are “unsafe and unworkable”, as a Cork University Hospital (CUH) consultant warned the HSE is not supporting its staff.
Their fears come as 603 people could not get a hospital bed on Monday. This included 79 at University Hospital Limerick and 35 at CUH, according to the Irish Nurses and Midwives Organisation.
Separate HSE data showed 32 people waited on trolleys longer than 24 hours, including one person aged over 75. At the same time, 561 patients finished treatment in various hospitals but could not leave due to gaps in community or rehabilitation care.
Healthcare staff say they are struggling to fill rosters to meet this rising demand, but health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has insisted spending is already too high, especially on pay.
This argument was backed on Sunday by HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor, who told RTÉ an overspend of €950m is expected by December.
Read More
The nurses and midwives letter says they reject the revised employment control processes. “These arrangements are unsafe and unworkable," the letter sent to the Department of Health on Monday said.
"They obstruct essential recruitment, undermine our professional judgment, expose patients and staff to foreseeable harm, and threaten our registration."
It warned staffing numbers should be based on patient need or how sick people are, not by “arbitrary employment ceilings or financial savings”.
Senior directors, including at CUH, Cork University Maternity Hospital, UHL, University Maternity Hospital Limerick, University Hospital Waterford, University Hospital Kerry and Tipperary University Hospital in Clonmel, signed.
Staff across all HSE regions, including the Dublin maternity hospitals, also signed.
“If safe staffing cannot be secured, services must be curtailed, or beds closed to protect patients,” the letter said. This echoes similar concerns from CUH chief executive Jennifer Kearney and doctors.
Also on Monday, Dr Greg Fulton, chair of the CUH consultants committee, criticised Ms O’Connor for not allowing an independent assessment of staff numbers.
“I think it’s fair to say that the staff have been really galvanised by their support for the (CUH) CEO who’s really been very effective in putting patient issues first,” he told RTÉ. “And also essentially they’ve been bound together by the absence of support from HSE central.”
He described staff as “particularly annoyed” by Ms O’Connor claiming people are fearful of attending meetings at CUH because they might be recorded.
This is “frankly ridiculous”, he said, stressing this is not the feedback from staff this week.
He repeated calls from the committee for an independent assessment of staff numbers compared to need in light of the hiring restrictions. He also said inspections by health regulator Hiqa are not what is needed for this issue.
“Hiqa are interested in patient safety; they don’t look at staff numbers”, he said, adding: “It is very misleading for anyone in the Department of Health or the HSE to suggest otherwise.”



