Paul Hosford: European leaders ask 'what's next' for Ukraine as coalition meets in Berlin

There is a wider European question about how much influence a continent can exercise when its security architecture remains so heavily dependent on American political and military commitment
UK prime minister Andy Burnham and Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky during the Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin, Germany. Picture: Hannah McKay/PA

UK prime minister Andy Burnham and Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelensky during the Coalition of the Willing meeting in Berlin, Germany. Picture: Hannah McKay/PA

In the seminal political TV drama The West Wing, the US president Josiah Bartlet is given a catchphrase by the writers in which he impatiently asks "what's next?"

The message given in the show is that when president Bartlet considers an issue dealt with he seeks to move on to the next most pressing concern.

On Thursday, some 43 leaders, ministers and ambassadors — as well as the US double act of Jared Kushner and Steve Witkoff — sought to ask and, to an extent, answer the question of what's next for Ukraine as the Coalition of the Willing met in Berlin.

Amid tight security, the ad-hoc group's Big Three — German chancellor Friedrich Merz, French president Emmanuel Macron and UK prime minister Andy Burnham — welcomed Ukrainian president Volodymyr Zelenskyy to a governmental quarter of the city which bore the hallmarks of Dublin during last week's European summits as workers appeared to have stayed home rather than run the gauntlet of barriers and checkpoints and road closures.

Inside the Federal Chancellery, amid security so tight that most journalists could not gain access after a surge in interest in recent days, the three European leaders and Mr Zelenskyy met before a plenary session attempted to nail down exactly what the coalition is looking for in any peace talks between Ukraine and Russia.

The coalition's members are attempting to demonstrate that Ukraine will not be left to negotiate its future alone and that any settlement must be backed by credible security guarantees. The message to Moscow is that European support for Kyiv is not simply a temporary political arrangement which can be waited out, with the Taoiseach saying as much when he took questions from the Irish media.

While Mr Kushner would say in the post-event press conference that Europe should be at the table, his mere presence alongside Mr Witkoff was a reminder that Washington has the capacity to shape the terms of any settlement in a way that individual European capitals, or even the coalition collectively, cannot. 

The question is whether the Americans see Europe as a partner in that process or as an audience to be briefed once the difficult decisions have been made. Mr Kushner's soundings were positive for Europe, but nothing is settled.

The Taoiseach's attendance underlines Ireland's support for Ukraine and its interest in a settlement which respects sovereignty and international law. 

But there is also a wider European question about how much influence a continent can exercise when its security architecture remains so heavily dependent on American political and military commitment.

There is little doubt that the coalition has value. It provides a forum for countries to coordinate their positions, demonstrate solidarity and prepare for the possibility of a ceasefire. But preparation is not the same as progress, and a declaration of unity is not a substitute for diplomatic leverage.

That leaves the question of what's next hanging over the gathering. Before leaders can seriously discuss the guarantees that might underpin a peace, they need to know whether there is a viable path to peace at all, and whether Europe will have a meaningful voice in determining its terms.

Otherwise, the coalition risks finding itself busily arranging the furniture for a negotiation to which it may not be invited.

  • Paul Hosford, Deputy Political Editor.

More in this section

Revoiced

Newsletter

Had a busy week? Sign up for some of the best reads from the week gone by. Selected just for you.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited