'It’s decision time,' says judge after third adjournment of Joshua Allen garda assault case

The eldest son of celebrity chef Rachel Allen faces nine charges which include allegedly driving a van at a garda, assaulting two gardaí, driving under the influence of cocaine and cannabis, and possessing ketamine and a knife
Joshua Allen (pictured) is charged with failing to stop a red Ford Transit van at a garda checkpoint and driving it 'at speed' at Garda Ciaran Cummins McCarthy, 'forcing him to take evasive action to avoid being struck, which created a substantial risk of death or serious harm to another'. File picture

Joshua Allen (pictured) is charged with failing to stop a red Ford Transit van at a garda checkpoint and driving it 'at speed' at Garda Ciaran Cummins McCarthy, 'forcing him to take evasive action to avoid being struck, which created a substantial risk of death or serious harm to another'. File picture

A judge said he was having “déjà vu” when a third adjournment was requested for MMA fighter Joshua Allen to either plead guilty or contest nine charges which include allegedly assaulting gardaí and possessing ketamine.

Judge Colm Roberts warned that it was "decision time" in his case. Mr Allen, aged 26, was due to enter a signed guilty plea or request a book of evidence at Midleton District Court on Thursday.

The eldest son of celebrity chef Rachel Allen faces nine charges which include allegedly driving a van at a garda, assaulting two gardaí, driving under the influence of cocaine and cannabis, and possessing ketamine and a knife.

All charges date from October 27, 2025, and were allegedly committed in the Shanagarry area of East Cork, near Ballymaloe House and Cookery School, which was founded by members of Mr Allen's family.

Mr Allen’s decision on whether to plead guilty or contest the charges was adjourned in September and October. There were also previous adjournments during the summer due to the solicitor’s strike over legal aid payments.

The case has been directed to be prosecuted on indictment in the circuit court. Judge Roberts said that it was “decision time” on whether Mr Allen would plead guilty or request a book of evidence to contest the charges.

“You have to make a decision,” Judge Roberts said at Midleton District Court on Thursday.

Defence solicitor Don Ryan said that he was in ongoing communication with the Director of Public Prosecution on the case, having spoken to an officer there as recently as this morning. The DPP had requested that the case be adjourned for two weeks, Mr Ryan said.

Judge Roberts asked: “Is there a certain déjà vu going on Mr Ryan?” He asked if the talks Mr Ryan was having with the DPP involved new issues. But Mr Ryan said that they did not.

“Matters are ongoing between myself and the DPP’s office. I’m just asking for two weeks,” Mr Ryan said. Judge Robers replied that while he did not want to be unreasonable, he was hearing the same thing at multiple court sittings.

“It’s not your concern that cases are being adjourned, it’s not the State’s concern that cases are being adjourned, but it is my concern. 

I’d like to be part of this decision rather than a passive recipient. Because I’m not really a passive recipient, it is not my thing. 

Mr Ryan said the process had only begun in October 2025 and that the case was progressing. But Judge Roberts said there was supposed to be either a signed guilty plea or a book of evidence requested in September.

Mr Ryan said he was only asking for an additional two weeks. Court presenter Sgt Linda O’Leary said that she had also spoken to the DPP’s office this morning about the case.

She said she was confident that the case would be dealt with in two weeks. “What’s remaining are minor issues,” she said.

Judge Ryan said that the multiple adjournments were unfair on the defendant. “When he turns up, a lot of media turn up too, it’s not fair on him,” Judge Roberts said.

He remanded Mr Allen on continuing bail until December 3.

But he warned that a decision on whether he would plead guilty or not must be made on that date. “It’s decision time. As in, again, it is decision time. It was meant to be in September,” he said.

Mr Allen attended court alone, wearing a beige shirt and black jacket. His blonde hair was neatly cropped. He did not speak during the hearing.

The court previously heard that an “issue” had arisen in the case and it was adjourned to allow a new witness to give a statement.

Charges against Joshua Allen

Mr Allen, the eldest son of TV chef and author Rachel Allen, is charged with failing to stop a red Ford Transit van at a garda checkpoint and driving it "at speed" at Garda Ciaran Cummins McCarthy, "forcing him to take evasive action to avoid being struck, which created a substantial risk of death or serious harm to another".

He is also charged with dangerous driving on the R629 at Monagurra, Shanagarry, on October 27, 2025, and with driving while intoxicated on the R632 on the same date, having tested positive for cocaine and cannabis.

Five other charges relate to Shanagarry South, Ballycotton, including assault causing harm to Garda Patrick Costello, assaulting Garda Ciaran Cummins McCarthy and resisting the garda while he was executing his duty.

Mr Allen is further charged with unlawful possession of ketamine and possessing a sharply pointed knife. His final charge relates to dangerous driving at Shanagarry North, Co Cork.

He previously competed in mixed martial arts, having won a championship in Cork, and works as a stonemason and runs his own stonemasonry business.

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited