Family's trust in hospital system 'profoundly affected' by loved one's death at UHL

Geraldine O’Loughlin, 70, died on July 7, 2023, at UHL, two weeks after her admission
Eoin O'Shaughnessy, Patricia and Catherine O'Loughlin, Kenneth and Pamela O'Loughin at Geraldine O'Loughlin's inquest at Kilmallock Coroner's Court. Picture: Brendan Gleeson

Eoin O'Shaughnessy, Patricia and Catherine O'Loughlin, Kenneth and Pamela O'Loughin at Geraldine O'Loughlin's inquest at Kilmallock Coroner's Court. Picture: Brendan Gleeson

A family has said their trust in the hospital system has been "profoundly affected" after a medical misadventure verdict in their loved one's death at University Hospital Limerick (UHL).

Geraldine O’Loughlin, 70, died on July 7, 2023, at UHL, two weeks after her admission.

At her inquest at the Coroner’s Court in Kilmallock, Limerick coroner John McNamara returned the medical misadventure verdict as well as recommending that UHL review its procedures and the education of its staff.

Upon her arrival at the hospital, the court heard Ms O'Loughlin was triaged as Category 2 and moved into the resuscitation unit. A day later, she was intubated and brought to the ICU.

Once the tube was eventually removed, Ms O’Loughlin suffered a cardiac arrest, and subsequently died on July 7.

The autopsy found the cause of death was cardiorespiratory failure, desquamative interstitial pneumonia, as well as aspiration.

Mr McNamara noted the deceased had some underlying medical conditions which included a gastric and colonic hiatus hernia, but was also a very “active lady” who lived a “very full life”.

He found that unintended complication, including omissions in monitoring or escalation, “caused or materially contributed” to her worsening condition.

He said that whilst his verdict reflects an unintended fatal outcome associated with medical care, it does not find negligence, or determine civil or criminal liabilities.

Throughout the proceedings, a key element discussed was the Irish National Early Warning System (INEWS), used to recognise and escalate acute clinical deterioration. During the inquest, it was argued the escalation protocol had not been followed despite the patient’s very high score.

Mr McNamara recommended UHL review procedures linked to the scores to ensure timely medical review for “patient safety” and to prevent “future fatalities”.

He also recommended that UHL review its “education for staff” when it comes to “accurate and contemporaneous documentation” of assessments.

He said Ms O’Loughlin’s family carried themselves with “great decorum”.

Upon her arrival at  University Hospital Limerick, the court heard Ms O'Loughlin was triaged as Category 2 and moved into the resuscitation unit. A day later, she was intubated and brought to the ICU. Picture: Dan Linehan
Upon her arrival at  University Hospital Limerick, the court heard Ms O'Loughlin was triaged as Category 2 and moved into the resuscitation unit. A day later, she was intubated and brought to the ICU. Picture: Dan Linehan

“Sometimes we can't get all the answers, but I hope some of the evidence, findings and recommendations help you deal with your mam's passing,” he said.

As he gave the verdict, Ms O’Loughlin’s four children exhaled “yes” before comforting each other.

After the hearing, her daughter Catherine said they hope the verdict would lead to positive change.

“She was the best mother and grandmother we could have ever wished for. After the death of our father at a young age, she raised the four of us on her own, facing every challenge with extraordinary resilience, unwavering love and complete devotion."

Catherine, a nurse, said that despite voicing concerns regarding her mother’s deterioration, her care was “not escalated properly”.

In the ICU, her mother was a “fighter until her very last breath”.

The family’s main concern was the “incorrect calculation” of her INEWS score, which led to doctors failing to “escalate her care appropriately”.

“Our experience has profoundly affected our trust in the hospital system. Every patient deserves safe, timely and compassionate care," said Catherine.

“We cannot bring our Mam back, but we hope that by speaking out, it will help prevent another family from experiencing the heartbreak we have endured”.

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited