CUH row: Micheál Martin says leaked recording is 'symptomatic of problems'
CUH chief executive Jennifer Kearney and Taoiseach Micheál Martin as the row continues. Picture: Noel Sweeney
Taoiseach Micheál Martin has dismissed the suggestion that there should be retribution for those who recorded meetings at Cork University Hospital (CUH), but that it is “symptomatic of the problems” at the hospital.
He urged everyone to “get around the table” as tensions among senior management and the HSE continue to grow.
In August, CUH chief executive Jennifer Kearney wrote to senior HSE officials warning of a shortfall of about 1,000 staff, caused by recruitment restrictions and delays in approving posts.
She urgently sought the prioritisation of 172 posts before the busy winter season.
Health minister Jennifer Carroll MacNeill has repeatedly dismissed concerns around staffing, saying CUH has hired twice as many staff as had been budgeted for, and suggested that CUH was not managing its affairs properly.
At a meeting shortly after Ms Kearney’s letter was made public, HSE South West chief Andy Phillips warned of possible “performance management” action at CUH to bring the hospital up to standard.
Read More
At the meeting, a recording of which was released to the media, Mr Phillips claimed the offices of Taoiseach Mr Martin and Ms Carroll MacNeill had instructed him to speak to Ms Kearney.
HSE chief executive Anne O’Connor suggested the meeting of senior HSE and hospital staff was “illegally recorded".
Speaking to the , the Taoiseach said he was concerned about the recording being leaked.
He echoed these comments on Monday, but dismissed suggestions that the person who made the recording should be punished.
“Obviously, it's symptomatic of problems, it would seem to me, or interpersonal issues, or issues between different areas of responsibility within the broader HSE group,” he said.
“I think that needs to be resolved.”
The Taoiseach said there is a “need for people to get around the table” but noted that the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) had made an “unannounced visit” to CUH.
He noted that Hiqa found it is “in line with other hospitals in respect of patient safety”.
“We can't have alternative processes that determine patient safety, other than the established ones,” he said.
“There has to be due rigour and due diligence around patient safety, and that's the point I have to make to the clinicians and to everybody.
"It's not just enough for people to make statements. It has to be validated. That's why we have the Health Quality Information body.
"That's why it was established. That's why we have the National Patient Safety Office.”
Mr Martin said that while there is “no question” there is pressure on CUH, there is pressure across “acute hospital services in the last six weeks”.
He said no issue is going to be solved by “megaphone engagement” and urged people to “engage in a constructive, sensible way”.




