'What is a woman?' Sinn Féin to circulate new policy document on transgender issues
Sinn Féin president Mary Lou McDonald described the document as 'really positive' and 'really progressive'. Picture: Sam Boal/Collins Photos
Sinn Féin is preparing to circulate a new policy document on transgender issues to its TDs and senators, but its leader insists that there is no rowing back from the party.
The document, which has not yet been published, includes guidance on how elected representatives should respond to questions about transgender issues, including the question: “What is a woman?”
According to the draft briefing notes advise representatives to say: “Like most people, I see a woman as an adult female. There are also trans women.”
The accompanying explanation reportedly defines a trans woman as someone recorded as male at birth who identifies and lives as a woman.
Speaking in Kilkenny on Tuesday, Ms McDonald rejected suggestions that Sinn Féin was retreating from its support for transgender people.
She described the document as “really positive” and “really progressive”, insisting it represented a clarification of existing policy rather than a reversal.
She said the guidance set out the party's position on respect and inclusion and was intended to provide greater clarity for representatives.
Ms McDonald also rejected suggestions that the move was motivated by electoral considerations, arguing that the debate should be about people's rights and personal security.
The policy follows a period of considerable internal discussion, including a special party conference on gender identity in July 2025.
One of the most significant issues concerns whether 16- and 17-year-olds should be allowed to legally determine their own gender.
"For me and for us, the important part of all of this is to ensure we get this thing right," Ms McDonald said.
“Part of getting it right is a balance when it comes to young people, and by that I mean people who have not reached the age of 18...the balance between parental care, parental consent, parental concern, and the rights and autonomy of an emerging adult.
"I think we struck that balance in the document.”
The debate has also been complicated by developments in Northern Ireland, where the Stormont Executive supported restrictions on puberty blockers for young people.
Sinn Féin faced criticism from transgender advocacy groups over its position in the North and was excluded from the Dublin Trans and Intersex Pride march in 2025 amid concerns about its approach to transgender rights.
The controversy intensified following a UK Supreme Court judgement last year which found that the terms woman and sex in the Equality Act 2010 referred to biological sex.
Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane initially welcomed the judgment as a “common sense” decision, prompting criticism from transgender campaigners and within his own party.
He subsequently apologised for the hurt and offence caused by his comments.
The party's 2024 health manifesto had supported gender recognition and appropriate healthcare for transgender people.
Speaking on Tuesday, Mr Cullinane said that he was right to delete that post because he does not "believe that X was the place to deal with a complex issue”.
“I simply make the point that legally in this State, a person can transition, and if a person transitions...they live their life as a woman.
"Let them be, let them live their lives as they are, and respect them and value them and show them dignity,” he added.




