'Fianna Fáil has become more Fine Gael than Fine Gael themselves,' says Mary Lou McDonald
Taoiseach Micheal Martin (left) and Tánaiste Simon Harris. The Sinn Féin leader said Fine Gael had described Ireland's neutrality as a ‘sham’ in 2003 while Fianna Fáil had called the Triple Lock the 'core of Irish neutrality'. Photo: Liam McBurney/PA
Sinn Féin leader Mary Lou McDonald has suggested that “Fianna Fáil has become more Fine Gael than Fine Gael themselves” as she accused it of shifting its stance on the Triple Lock and Irish neutrality.
Ms McDonald accused the Taoiseach of “dishonesty, sleight of hand and duplicity”, while Micheál Martin accused Ms McDonald of being “reckless” and “putting Defence Forces personnel at risk” with her comments about future Irish missions.
The Triple Lock continues to dominate Dáil proceedings, with Sinn Féin now having four of its last five Leaders’ Questions focused on the issue. The Oireachtas Defence Committee is expected to start debating the Government’s legislation to remove the Triple Lock next week.
The Government is proposing the removal of the requirement for an overseas Defence Forces mission to require a United Nations (UN) mandate before troops are sent overseas. The Government has cited concerns that permanent members of the Security Council — comprised of the United Kingdom, the United States, Russia, China, and France — can veto missions.
Irish peacekeepers will withdraw from Lebanon by the end of the year due to the United States’ blockage of the United Nations Interim Force in Lebanon (UNIFIL).
In the Dáil, Ms McDonald referenced the Taoiseach’s 2013 comments suggesting that the Triple Lock was at the “core of Irish neutrality”, arguing that he had “rejected attempts at that time to remove it”.
Read More
“Now you carry out that very assault on neutrality that you once condemned,” she said.
“We also know that your partners in government in Fine Gael have long wished to dispatch with Irish neutrality and the triple lock. As far back as 2003 they described our neutrality as a ‘sham’. You condemned that agenda then. You called that out then.
“But in the time since then, Fianna Fáil has become more Fine Gael than Fine Gael themselves.”
Ms McDonald said there was a “proposed mission to Lebanon” being discussed by the EU, and asked: “To what extent does this involve intelligence sharing, operation co-ordination and planning with Israel?"
She also noted that “many of the [European] capitals that the Taoiseach looks [to] for approval represent former colonial powers”.
The Taoiseach argued that Ms McDonald was talking about “former imperial powers”, and not “current imperial powers”, such as Russia. He also referred to a “former colonial power that Sinn Féin is very friendly with, the United Kingdom”, questioning why the party wanted Russia and the UK to have a veto on Irish peacekeeping missions.
Mr Martin also rebuked Ms McDonald’s suggestion that Ireland would work on any missions associated with Israel.
“I ask you not to imply in any shape or form that the Irish Defence Forces would be supporting Israel or siding with it on this peacekeeping mission,” he said. “That endangers the lives of Irish soldiers currently in Lebanon. It is reckless on your behalf.
“It is wrong and it is an untruth. The deputy should not be saying it. There are peacekeepers with UNIFIL in Lebanon right now endeavouring to fulfil Resolution 1701 as a peacekeeping mission. You are, by your commentary, putting them at risk, and you should not do that.”
- Louise Burne, political correspondent




