'He does seem to be a little accident prone': Court asks for verification of defendant's ill health
The court heard that the offending occurred between November 10, 2020, and March 5, 2021, involving 72 incidents of catalytic converters being stolen in the Clare area. Many of the victims were elderly and lived in rural areas, with the converters sold to certain scrap yards.
The Court of Appeal has asked for verification regarding the hospitalisation of a man who was due to be resentenced for his part in a criminal organisation that targeted elderly people when stealing catalytic converters.
Mr Justice Charles Meenan, presiding at the three-judge court, remarked that John Doherty, aged 29, "does seem to be a little accident-prone" after hearing that this was the second time the defendant had failed to show up due to health matters.
"We need to see verification that this is a genuine matter," said Mr Justice Alexander Owens, as the court requested reports proving that Doherty was too ill to attend court on Wednesday morning.
While it was accepted that Doherty was not the mastermind of the criminal organisation, the court previously found that he was not “an innocent abroad” in an enterprise featuring 72 incidents of catalytic converters being stolen, mainly from elderly people living in rural areas.
Doherty, of St Michael’s Park, Ballymaley, Ennis, Co Clare, was sentenced by Judge Francis Comerford to 32 months in prison with the last 26 months suspended at Ennis Courthouse in July 2025.
He had pleaded guilty to participating in or contributing to the activities of a criminal organisation contrary to section 72 of the Criminal Justice Act 2006, as substituted by Section 6 of the Criminal Justice Act (Amendment) Acto 2009.
The court heard that the offending occurred between November 10, 2020, and March 5, 2021, involving 72 incidents of catalytic converters being stolen in the Clare area. Many of the victims were elderly and lived in rural areas, with the converters sold to certain scrap yards.
He had 16 previous convictions.
In bringing an appeal of undue leniency in October, Maddie Grant, for the DPP, said the sentencing judge set a headline sentence of 60 months. However, there was an error in principle when the judge reduced this to 32 months before suspending the final 26 months, she said, leaving a period of incarceration of six months in prison with 26 months suspended.
Doherty has now completed that sentence.
Ms Grant pointed out that there had been almost a 50% reduction from the headline sentence of 60 months to 32 months.
Counsel also referenced a transcript from the sentencing court where it appeared that the judge had meant to impose a final sentence of eight months, and when it was pointed out to him that the sentence was six, the judge said it wasn’t his intent but he would give Doherty the benefit.
In delivering the court’s judgment, Mr Justice Paul Burns said the offending was of a serious nature, with the offenders going to considerable lengths to prevent detection.
He said that, while not the mastermind, Doherty played a significant role in sourcing vehicles to be used in the thefts and cloning number plates, so he was “not an innocent abroad”.
Ruling that six months in prison was unduly lenient, the court said it would quash the sentence and resentence Doherty, with the matter adjourned to Wednesday.
When the matter returned to court in the morning, Aaron Desmond, for Doherty, said his client had taken ill and required a brain scan, so he was not present in court.
Mr Justice Owens said this was the second time this had happened, as he had previously dealt with the defendant in Cork and on that occasion Doherty did not turn up as it was suggested he had been in an accident.
Mr Justice Meenan said that an MRI report was needed as was a detailed report concerning Doherty's current admission to hospital.
The matter was adjourned for three weeks.




