'Diluted' Leaving Cert maths curriculum would leave students underprepared for college, experts warn
Engineers Ireland said: 'The proposed removal or reduction of topics such as complex numbers, mathematical induction and aspects of advanced trigonometric manipulation may adversely affect students' readiness for mathematically intensive engineering programmes at third level.' File picture
A "diluted" maths curriculum poses serious risks to Ireland's competitiveness, mathematicians, engineers, and academics have warned as they call for proposed changes to the Leaving Cert subject to be withdrawn.
It comes as the National Council for Curriculum and Assessment (NCCA) public consultation on the proposed changes to Leaving Cert maths closed this week.
Forming part of wider Senior Cycle reforms, the changes were cast in the spotlight earlier this year when it emerged two expert members of the NCCA subject redevelopment group resigned, citing issues with the process.
The Irish Mathematical Society (IMS), Engineers Ireland, Rinn AI and the STEM Schools at University College Dublin each provided detailed written submissions to the NCCA as part of the three-month public consultation process.
Each of the groups expressed serious concerns about the proposals in their current format, raising issues with aspects of the draft curriculum like the reduction of some of the more analytical and abstract elements of maths, and the introduction of Additional Assessment Components (AACs).
Read More
A failure to thoroughly review the impact of 'bonus points' for higher level maths is also cited, as is the fear the changes may adversely affect students' readiness for programmes at third level.
In its submission, the IMS recommended the current curriculum review process be paused, citing "critical issues" such as a lack of international benchmarking as well as "the under-preparation of students for further study, and the subsequent risk to STEM industries based on the reduction of mathematical knowledge and skills of post-primary students".
The vast majority of its members believe the proposed content of both the Higher and Ordinary Level curricula will not adequately prepare students for study in further and higher education, it noted.
Engineers Ireland said it has significant concerns regarding the potential reduction of maths that traditionally formed an important foundation for problem-solving and progression into engineering education.
"The proposed removal or reduction of topics such as complex numbers, mathematical induction and aspects of advanced trigonometric manipulation may adversely affect students' readiness for mathematically intensive engineering programmes at third level."
A submission was also provided to the NCCA on behalf of both the College of Science and College of Engineering and Architecture at UCD. The unified stance across UCD’s Science and Engineering faculties should send a clear message to the minister, said Professor Andrew Hines.
"These changes risk long-term negative effects across STEM education. The best course of action is to withdraw the current Draft Specifications and re-evaluate.
"A diluted secondary curriculum will have serious downstream effects," he added. "Higher failure rates at third level and less ambitious degree programmes. The diminished student potential will create severe long-term knock-on effects for Ireland’s knowledge economy and society.
"Shifting assessment away from pure mathematical proficiency and problem-solving strength will build iniquity into the system by favouring students from privileged backgrounds who possess greater access to external coaching and presentation tools."
A spokesperson for the NCCA said the Mathematics Development Group will reconvene on December 10 to begin to consider feedback gathered through the consultation. "Meetings will continue in 2027 with the Development Group having the necessary time to work on and finalise the specification."
- Jess Casey, education correspondent




