Head of HSE admits she has not engaged with CUH CEO Jennifer Kearney as staffing dispute continues 

Jennifer Kearney, CEO of CUH, and Anne O'Connor, CEO of the HSE. File picture 

Jennifer Kearney, CEO of CUH, and Anne O'Connor, CEO of the HSE. File picture 

Cork University Hospital CEO Jennifer Kearney is being subjected to a 'witchhunt', it has been claimed, as the head of the HSE admitted she has not even spoken to her about the staffing row which emerged in August.

Anne O'Connor made the admission at the Oireachtas health committee. At the same committee, the position of the HSE Southwest regional officer Dr Andy Philips, who has clashed with Ms Kearney, was called into question as Ms O’ Connor declined to say she has “full confidence” in him.

As 73 patients waited on trolleys for a bed at the embattled Cork hospital due to overcrowding, a heated session of the Oireachtas health committee heard Ms O’ Connor criticise CUH for “conducting its management business via the media with extraordinary regularity”.

However when she was asked if she had spoken to Ms Kearney about her concerns by Sinn Féin health spokesman David Cullinane, she replied “No, not recently”.

A row over staffing has been ongoing since last August when Jennifer Kearney wrote to senior health officials to express concern about safety at the hospital heading into the winter.

Speaking after the committee, Mr Cullinane said the priority for people in Cork must be to “sort out the hospital” in relation to staff shortages and overcrowding.

“We must not lose sight of that,” he said, also describing as “hypocritical” Ms O’ Connor’s comments about CUH and the media.

“She needs to meet Jennifer Kearney, Andy Philips and whoever else is necessary to be there, there needs to be a resolution," he said.

Safety concerns have already motivated an additional inspection by the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) at CUH.

A Hiqa spokesman said on Wednesday this was on November 5 and 6 and that it has requested the HSE to provide it with information "to inform our findings".

Ms O’ Connor also told TDs at the committee that there is an internal process ongoing in HSE Southwest which she said is being led by Kevin Foley, former Labour Court chairman.

This followed concerns raised internally by managers in HSE Southwest last year. These were “in terms of working within the region” she told Social Democrats TD Liam Quaide.

A HSE spokesman said after the hearing: “The HSE CEO is aware of a number of issues that have arisen in the South West. "There is currently a process underway to support resolution and it would not be appropriate to comment further on it at this point.” 

Asked by Senator Laura Harmon if she has “full confidence” in Andy Philips, Ms O’ Connor responded: “As I said previously I have confidence but I’m also very conscious there is a lot of work to be done in the Southwest.” 

 Speaking afterwards Ms Harmon said: “What is left for the HSE Southwest region if the regional executive officer has had financial responsibility taken away from him, recruitment responsibility taken away from him and now the HSE ceo won’t even say she has full confidence in him."

Safety concerns have already motivated an additional inspection by the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) at CUH. File picture: Dan Linehan
Safety concerns have already motivated an additional inspection by the Health Information and Quality Authority (Hiqa) at CUH. File picture: Dan Linehan

Similarly when Labour TD Eoghan Kenny asked if Dr Philips’ position is “tenable” in light of controversy over comments he made at a meeting, Ms O’ Connor said: “I’m not going to get into that in this forum, there’s work underway within the region.”

In the Dail, Labour leader Ivana Ms Bacik questioned if the Government wants to “silence those who speak out about failings in the health service”.

“Is the CEO of the HSE suggesting that Jennifer Kearney has done something wrong?” she asked the Taoiseach. “If so, what? This looks like a witch hunt, Taoiseach. Jennifer Kearney has not given media interviews about her letter.

“She used official channels to raise her concerns in the spring and early summer. As the winter drew nearer, having received no substantive response, she wrote the strongly worded letter setting out profound concerns for patient safety."

Ms Bacik said that it wasn’t Ms Kearney who inflamed the situation, rather a “HSE regional manager who used false political threats”.

This is referring to Dr Philips who apologised for telling Ms Kearney that he had been instructed by the Taoiseach's office to have “very specific conversations with her”.

The Taoiseach said he had met with Ms Kearney in October but would have preferred to meet her before she started sending letters, and they made their way into the media.

He insisted there is a process in place, which involves HSE Chief Clinical Officer Colm Henry, and CUH.

“Hiqa has to be involved, the National Patient Safety Office,” Mr Martin said. “It just can't be you or I or others saying, ‘I'm putting my hand up’ and saying, ‘There's a safety issue’.

“There has to be a systemic basis, has to be standards and metrics that govern whether there is a safety risk or not. Then there's a separate issue about resources, in terms of advancement, development, and so on like that.”

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited