Angry Fans

OUR football correspondent LIAM MACKEY is back in top form and full of energy.

Angry Fans

He casts his eye over your comments and gives his own critical analysis of the

goings on throughout the world of football. You may agree with him or then again

you may not. This week Is Rafa 67.33 per cent confident of winning league; Keane’s

kick in the teeth; Shearer hypocritical on Match of the Day; Ince is doomed; Is

there a worse referee than Mike Riley; Scolari’s persistence with Deco; Scolari

another foreign flop; Love to be a fly on the wall at Man City’s next board

meeting; He plays with a smile; Let’s have your tips Liam; Ireland’s

return;

The Letter of the Week goes to Sean Stevens, Kildare get in touch with

your postal address and your magnificent prize will be winging its way to you.

SO Liam, after Liverpool’s failure to beat Hull at the weekend do you think

that Rafael Benitez might now be 67.333% recurring confident that the Reds will

win the Premier League title this season?

Limerick Red, by email AFTER

Robbie Keane’s desperate lung-busting efforts in Europe in midweek wasn’t

it a kick in the teeth for him not even to spring him from the bench when we needed

three points against Hull instead of one. He’s surely on his way, isn’t

he? Once again Liverpool have escaped because of the surprising failures of other

title rivals. It’s got to be our year.

Niall O’Keefe, Dublin,

by email

DIRK Kuyt has occasional good games, strangely best when he’s

playing wide on the right, but he was lamentable on Saturday and should have been

replaced by Robbie Keane. Lucas Leiva. WHY???????????

Anfield Roader, by

email

OUR SHOUT: If Benitez gave Keane a decent run of games,

he’d be repaid with goals, no question. But if he’s not going to give

him that chance, Robbie would be better off elsewhere.

WATCHING Match of

the Day and listening to Alan Shearer complaining about centre-forwards shoving

other players to gain an advantage is a bit like hearing sailors complain about

the sea isn’t it?

Anthony Keane, West Cork, by email

OUR

SHOUT: Ho, ho, ho and a bottle of rum.

YOU just know that people’s

careers are doomed when they start talking about themselves in the third person.

For this reason I fully expect Paul Ince to be gone by Christmas after his post-match

interviews following another dreadful performance at Wigan — “This is

not about Paul Ince. It doesn’t matter about Paul Ince etc“. Time to

call for the men in the white coats.

Padraig O’Connell, Dublin, by

email

OUR SHOUT: Oh, well, at least he didn’t say, “This

is not about The Guvnor. It doesn’t matter about The Guvnor” etc.

FOR

the second game in succession an official has had a clear impact on the outcome

of an important match at Stamford Bridge. Two weeks ago Robin Van Persie was clearly

offside when he equalised, a decision which resulted in the suspension of a linesman

for one game. On Sunday Mike Riley — is there a worse referee officiating

in the modern game — ignored a nailed-on penalty when Lampard was brought

down by Lucas Neill. It’s no excuse for Neill to say that he couldn’t

get out of the way. With proper officiating Chelsea could be five points better

off and away at the top of the league. Is this some master plan to ensure that

we have a close title race this season?

Cork Blue, by email

ARE

we witnessing something interesting with Scolari at Chelsea, vindication of the

theory that just because you’re a good international manager it doesn’t

follow that you can do the job at club level? His persistence with Deco, who is

clearly out of form, rekindles memories of a similar obstinacy with Portugal where

he was often accused of playing his favourites. Playing one up front at home against

a West Ham side who were taken apart by Tottenham a few days previously has the

whiff of madness about it. And while much has been made of their away record it

has been achieved against lower level clubs. Starting with Everton next Monday

they still have to visit Old Trafford, Anfield, White Hart Lane, Villa Park and

the Emirates. I don’t think the 100% record will last through that series

of games. In fact you can start getting those “Chelsea crisis” headlines

ready for the New Year Liam.

Fin O’Reilly, Cork, by email

SCOLARI

is just going to prove himself one more expensive foreign flop. Why do owners

and chairmen keep appointing people with limited understanding of Premier League

football. As far as I can see it’s succeeded twice with Wenger and Mourinho.

Now Sunderland are said to be interested in taking on Mancini as manager. Can

you see that working out? No, neither can I.

Black Cat, Waterford, by email

OUR SHOUT: Well, let’s see now — the clubs which have

dominated English (and even European) football in recent years have been managed

by the likes of Mourinho, Wenger and Benitez. Flops, eh? And don’t forget,

Fergie is a foreigner too. (Just ask him, via a translator). By the way, nice

to see Cork Blue back in the in-tray in time for the annual handing out of cards.

Red ones, of course.

STEWART Downing valued at ?16.2m including Gareth

Bale; Roque Santa Cruz carrying a price tag of 20m; Emile Heskey valued at 12m;

Ashley Young priced at 32m? Will someone ever tell football that there’s

a global recession on? Or has the game just become the equivalent of Rome’s

“bread and circuses.” And we all know what happened to Rome in the end.

Steve

O’Mahony, Limerick, by email

OUR SHOUT: Don’t tell

me. I haven’t finished reading the book.

CAN you just imagine the

conversations at the next board meeting at the City of Manchester stadium . .

. “Yes, I know we’ve spent all that money Sheikh. And I know 22m of

it went on Jo, but I really can’t explain why we’re one point off the

relegation zone. Another 100m or so for Kaka and Buffon should sort it out. Oh,

and wages of 400,000 a week will do nicely too.” Anyone think that the clock

is ticking ever more quickly for Mark Hughes. Perhaps they should get Sven back?

After all City were in the top four this time last year.

Donal McReedy,

Galway, by email

OUR SHOUT: Sven? If money’s no object

why they just get yer man from Manchester’s poor relations?

ISN’T

there a case for retrospective discipline against players who simulate either

to earn a penalty or to get opponents sent off. That dreadful piece of performance

art by John Pantsil was a clear attempt to get Ricardo Fuller sent off, and if

it had been performed in a theatre the audience would be catcalling and throwing

rotten tomatoes and cabbages at the actor concerned.

Sean Stevens, Kildare,

by email

OUR SHOUT: You haven’t been to the theatre since

medieval times, have you Steve. Still, have out Letter of the Week prize for some

righteous naming and shaming.

LIAM — I expect you watched that fantastic

match at Thomond Park on Saturday. What with that and All Black Dan Carter turning

out for Perpignan for 40,000 a match do you think that rugby is the new football?

Daniel

Grady. Tipperary, by email

OUR SHOUT: Oh absolutely. I mean,

there must be at least a dozen countries playing the game by now. If not more.

OK Liam, we’re half-way through the season. Let’s have your tips.

Who will be the Premier League champions, who will win the Champions League, and

will Ireland qualify for the World Cup. Quick now.

Pat Keating, Limerick,

by email

OUR SHOUT: Manchester United, Barcelona and I’ll

get back to your after the play-off.

STEPHEN Ireland’s father says

his son may be willing to break his self-imposed exile from the Irish national

team. Good news, or bad news, Liam?

Conor Murphy, West Cork, by email

OUR

SHOUT: No news at all — until we see what the prodigal son has to say

for himself.

More in this section

Sport

Newsletter

Latest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers. and reporters

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited