Angry Fans

The Examiner’s football correspondent Liam Mackey likes a good argument when he hears it, and he’s got strong views of his own.

Angry Fans

Every week he will be acting as referee on your opinions on the Premiership. Let him know what you think and he’ll argue the toss with you. We’ll be offering a free sports prize to the star contribution each week. This week Galway’s new manager a gamble; Fergie team selection costs Prem; Drogba misses big moment; Cork Blue gets bitchy; Barcelona to score twice; Ferdinand doesn’t have credentials for captaincy; Spurs sign Modric; Giles a joke; PFA team of the season a joke; Is goal difference fair.

Letter of the week goes Steve Heylin, West Cork for his letter on why Sven deserves another year. Let’s have that address and our prize will be winging its way to you.

GALWAY United have taken something of a gamble in the appointment of Jeff Kenna

as their new manager. Rooted to the bottom of the Eircom Premier League with only

a single point on the board so far means the former Republic Of Ireland International

will have his work cut out for him from the word go. His brief is straightforward:

keep Galway in the Premier League. Kenna was non-committal on whether or not sufficient

funds would be made available in July when the domestic transfer window opens.

It would be a real fairy-tale story if Kenna could keep Galway up at the

end of the season so good luck to him and the Galway supporters.

Ger McCarthy,

Cork, by email

OUR SHOUT: Yeah, good luck to Kenna and the

Tribesman — but I still think they were ridiculously hasty in getting rid

of Tony Cousins.

ALEX Ferguson might have dropped his gum in the tunnel

at Stamford Bridge on Saturday, but more importantly he could also have dropped

the Premier League trophy. Just what was the man thinking of playing a weakened

team against a fired-up Chelsea? It was arrogance of the highest order and it

has come back to bite him on the bum. As soon as I saw the team selection I knew

it was a mistake. You have to beat the opposition that’s in front of you,

and not worry about the next game. That will take care of itself.

Red

Devil, Limerick, by email

JUST where was Drogba when the big balls

moment — the penalty — came along on Saturday afternoon? Ballack was

there wanting it. As one of the papers said today, Drogba may have won the battle

over who takes free-kicks outside the area, but it was the German who won the

war.

Steve O’Connor, Cork, by email

A LOT has been

made of Ferguson dropping Ronaldo on Saturday, but the Portuguese rarely has a

good game against Chelsea in general, or Ashley Cole in particular and I could

see why he did it. What is apparent from that game is that Nani is probably two

more seasons away from being an acceptable replacement; that Anderson is too young

and inexperienced to be pitched into a Premier League match like that; and that

Carrick is nowhere near the quality of a €23m central midfielder. Ferguson

got what he deserved. The word of the day is hubris. I also hope that those lads

from Tralee waving the Irish tricolour in the front row of the United section

in the Shed Upper not only enjoyed their trip to Stamford Bridge but also the

after-match entertainment that our ground staff organised for them.

Cork

Blue, by email

WE’VE been hearing all season that Barcelona

is a busted flush, that Rijkaard is finished there, and that Henry is having a

miserable time. Me, after watching the game on Wednesday night, I’m worried.

Barcelona were quicker, more inventive, and had midfielders playing with intelligence.

I simply can’t see them not scoring at Old Trafford; in fact they could easily

get two. United are either going out or we’re in line for the game of the

season.

Finbarr Lynch, West Cork, by email

I THINK Saturday’s

contribution by Rio Ferdinand — lucky not to be sent off for mobbing the

referee and then, post-match, kicking a wall, missing it, and hitting a female

steward instead says everything we need to know about his credentials for international

captaincy, don’t you Liam?

Patrick Baker, Limerick, by email

OUR SHOUT: Well, he subsequently handed over a bouquet of flowers

so at least he’ll be good in the exchange of pennants before kick-off. As

for Finbarr Lynch on tonight’s match at Old Trafford — ever thought

that United could go out and we could still have the game of the season? Mind

you, for all Barca’s possession in the Nou Camp, I don’t recall them

creating too many clear-cut chances. Still, United have to come out to play this

time so, if nothing else, this should be a pretty lively affair. Anything else.

Oh yeah, a red for Cork Blue, which he can wave when Liverpool reach the final.

I GUESS that Tottenham’s haste to sign Luka Modric from Zagreb before

the end of the season can only mean one thing . . . that Dimitar Berbatov is on

his way. I only hope that it’s out of the Premier League and over to Spain

or Italy. Not to Old Trafford or Stamford Bridge, thank you very much.

Sean

McGuiness, Dublin, by email

OUR SHOUT: Arsenal would be

okay then, yeah?

YOU’VE got to laugh at Johnny Giles sometimes.

When he was on the RTE panel the other night he was asked whether Manchester United

or Chelsea will win the league. “United” he said, without a second thought

“by five or six points.” I do wonder whether these pundits actually

go to football any more. Most people know that United have been playing poorly

recently. I still expect them to take the title . . . but “by five or six

points?” My old nan could make better predictions.

Dennis Greene,

London, by email

OUR SHOUT: “My old nan”? That’s

no way to speak about Eamon Dunphy.

SO there are four Arsenal players

in the Professional Footballers Association team of the season. But the votes

are taken half way through the campaign. Which explains everything . . . because

they’ve all gone missing since February.

Disgruntled Gooner, Cork,

by email

CAN’T really quibble with the PFA team of the year

. . . but David James ahead of Petr Cech with the vote being taken before Portsmouth

had even reached the FA Cup Final? That’s got to be nonsense hasn’t

it?

Nick Kelly, Wexford, by email

OUR SHOUT: A

veritable calamity, you might say.

THE top of the table clash got the

headlines this weekend, but that game between Villa and Everton was fascinating

as well. I really think Villa have got what it takes to break through if they

can just make a couple of sensible signings this summer, and also hold onto Gareth

Barry. He’s doing a good job there on the quiet is O’Neill, as I always

thought he would.

Martin O’Keefe, Waterford, by email

OUR

SHOUT: Ecxuse me if I can’t come over all agog with excitement about

the doubtless pulsating race for a Uefa Cup spot.

Come on Liam . . .

who do you think’s going to win the big one? Will it be Toulouse or Munster

for you?

Mick Hennessey, Dublin, by email

OUR SHOUT:

Too close to call, Mick, but given it’s a European cup final, I wouldn’t

rule out Liverpool .

NICE TO hear that Sven is safe “for now.”

He’s had a decent enough first season and introduced some good players (as

well as some bad ones). Taking six points off United’s not so dusty and he

should have the chance at another campaign with City.

Steve Heylin, West

Cork, by email

OUR SHOUT: Steve, you have no hope of ever

becoming a football owner/chairman if you continue to spout complete sense like

this. Have out Letter Of The Week prize by way of consolation.

IS goal

difference really the best way to settle a league title over 38 games? Very few

of the other main sports adopt this yardstick, and in Spain it’s based on

the head-to-head record between the main contenders (in which case United would

win 3-2). Given the number of weakened teams that are put out at various stages

of the season by various clubs there’s got to be a more rational way to settle

the argument.

Tony Gallagher, Cork, by email

OUR SHOUT:

I know! How about a play-off between the top two — a 39th step, if you

will — in, say, San Diego. It’s so crazy it might just work!

More in this section

Sport

Newsletter

Latest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers. and reporters

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited