Islamic militants exploit Pope’s speech for all that wasn’t in it
For the past week Pope Benedict XVI and the Vatican have bent over backwards to stress how he regretted the misunderstanding following his quotation of a 14th century Christian emperor that characterised the Prophet Mohammed as having brought the world only evil and inhuman things.
“At this time, I wish also to add that I am deeply sorry for the reactions in some countries to a few passages of my address at the University of Regensburg which were considered offensive to the sensibility of Muslims. These in fact were a quotation from a medieval text, which do not in any way express my personal thought.”
As he said himself, his use of medieval quotes did not reflect his own conviction and were misunderstood.
What struck me was that if Catholics listened to every word the Pope uttered in the same way that the Muslims did last week, he would have a very intent audience indeed.
I would venture to say most Catholics hadn’t a clue Pope Benedict was at home in Germany, never mind what he said.
Now, thanks to the reaction from Muslims throughout the world, the Pope’s flock probably know his speech entitled ‘Faith, Reason and the University: Memories and Reflections’ off by heart.
Well, maybe they can’t recite his address at Regensburg, but there’s a good chance that if it comes up in a table quiz they’ll know of a 14th century Byzantine emperor called Manuel II Palaeologus.
Yet, despite the Pontiff’s efforts trying to unruffle those feathers, there are some — quite a few — determined to whip up extreme feelings among Muslims all over the world.
And that is the point. Muslim fundamentalists have stirred emotions and politicised this innocuous incident to an extreme degree. Papal effigies have been burned in Iraq where al-Qaida militants have vowed war on ‘worshippers of the Cross’.
The Supreme Leader in Iran, Ayatollah Ali Khamenei, described the Pope’s remark’s as “the latest chain of the crusade against Islam started by America’s Bush”.
If he, or his followers, took the trouble to find out he would realise the last thing most Catholic and other Christians support or admire is the Bush administration. The intolerance and naked hatred that erupted all over the world had absolutely nothing to do with religion.
Certainly it is no way related to any normal person’s conception of what any religion should be about.
At Basra in Iraq, about 150 demonstrators chanted slogans like ‘We gagged the Pope’, and burned an effigy of him, while in the West Bank and Gaza Strip several churches were petrol-bombed.
In the aftermath of Benedict’s address, a 65-year-old Italian nun, Sr Leonella, who had spent 40 years working in Africa, was shot in the back at the women and children’s hospital in the Somali capital of Mogadishu.
What the cowardly murder achieved is incomprehensible except that it was linked to strong criticism of the Pope’s address by a radical Somali cleric.
In Indonesia, three Christian militants are due to be executed because they were found guilty of inciting attacks during religious rioting in 2000. They have pleaded innocent.
The three are probably regretting the controversy that has been raging because they were due to face the firing squad last month, but won a reprieve when the Pope intervened on their behalf.
Somehow, I don’t think he’s quite as big in Indonesia just now.
Muslims in Turkey, Iraq and the Palestinian territories demanded this week that Benedict make a clear apology for his remarks on Islam.
Injecting some semblance of commonsense into this whole charade is the Malaysian prime minister, who has accepted the Pontiff’s statement of regret.
But it was hedged by a ‘don’t do it again attitude’ because Abdullah Ahmad Badawi said he hoped there would be “no more statements that anger Muslims”.
I don’t know whether he was referring to the Pope in particular, or the world in general, but the message was that Muslims are not to be upset.
If they are, it might provoke another reaction like that from a hitherto unknown Islamic group calling itself the Army of Guidance. As it happens, ‘Guidance’ might be something of a misnomer because the group has pledged to strike at Christian targets in the Gaza Strip in retaliation.
“Every place relevant to Christians will be a target”, declared a member of the group, which should be more aptly named the Army of the Misguided.
IN Turkey, another land renowned for its laissez faire attitude to civil rights, protesters said Pope Benedict must make full amends before a planned trip next November — the first of his papacy to a Muslim nation.
Now I must admit to a smile when I read that because any Muslims I met on three visits to that country were fairly relaxed in their devotion to the faith.
It is a great country to visit not least because of its pleasant people who are much more interested in the euro than the thoughts of some 14th century emperor on the Prophet.
They are also, incidentally, far more familiar with the Irish language than with the newly resurrected Manuel II Palaelologus.
I also wondered whether any of the Turkish demonstrators who were members of a religious workers’ union faced towards the Ballincollig bypass when they were summoned to prayer.
It’s hard to disagree with Cardinal George Pell, head of the Catholic Church in Australia, when he referred to the link between religion and violence for many Islamists and their refusal to respond to criticism with rational arguments.
It goes without saying he was criticised by some Australian Muslims for his comments.
Despite everything, Pope Benedict seems to be an incurable optimist. He said he hoped the whole furore could eventually serve to encourage “positive and even self-critical dialogue both among religions as well as between modern reason and the faith of Christians”.
Oddly enough, the Pope said he had wanted to explain that religion and violence do not go together, but that religion and reason did.
A couple of million Muslims around the world obviously took a very different view, as the reverberations from Regensburg have shown.
Even Russian President Vladimir Putin urged world religious leaders to show “responsibility and restraint”.
All of that because he quoted some obscure figure from the dim mists of the 14th century whom the vast majority of Muslims, like the vast majority of Christians, had never heard of.
On the other hand, the Pope might have realised that figures from the past can stir a bit of controversy.
Just ask Dan Brown.




