Minister asked to intervene in Tuam Mother and Baby Home oversight board dispute
Annette McKay, whose sister Mary Margaret O’Connor was named as one of the 796 babies who died at the Tuam Mother and Baby Home. Picture: Ray Ryan
An internal dispute within the State oversight board for the Tuam Mother and Baby Home excavation has led committee members to call directly on the children's minister to intervene.
Annette McKay, a family representative on the Tuam Advisory Board, and whose sister Mary Margaret O’Connor is believed to be buried at the site along with nearly 800 other children, initially handed in a resignation notice to Norma Foley on October 7.
It is understood she raised questions about the board's current leadership, citing a difficult working relationship with the chairperson, Dr Brian Farrell, the practical independence of the board, and the weight given to family views.
While the direct dispute lies between Ms McKay and the chair, two other key board members have stepped forward to back her.
Ms McKay, who is calling for an independent review of the board’s leadership, has raised several concerns, including how Galway County Council attended nine of the 15 meetings since the establishment of the board in 2024, but was not included in the minutes of the meetings.
She has also raised concerns families were not receiving sufficient support as the exhumation of the children who died at the Tuam home continues. So far, 109 babies' remains have been recovered.
"The silencing of people’s voices has been a theme in the story of Tuam from the beginning, and it is not healthy that anyone on the board should feel that this is continuing," she said.
"I resigned because I had serious concerns about how the advisory board is led and run, and whether family representatives are genuinely being heard."
Read More
She has since withdrawn her resignation notice "as a temporary measure so that Tuam families would continue to have representation while the minister considers my concerns".
The Tuam Babies Family Group has also waded into the row, and has written directly to the minister in support of Ms McKay, warning families cannot once again be sidelined.
The standoff escalated when it emerged the chairperson, former Dublin City Coroner Brian Farrell, engaged in separate correspondence with Ms Foley to seek a meeting "on behalf of the board", a move the Department of Children confirmed to the .
A spokesperson said the minister "will be replying positively to that request shortly".
Ms McKay expressed "deep concern" over being left in the dark about the chair's correspondence to the minister, noting she was not consulted or told about the letter.
"He cannot speak for me or present my views as part of a collective board position," she said.
The Department of Children confirmed Ms McKay had officially rescinded her resignation and Ms Foley “will reflect carefully on the issues raised by Ms McKay in her letter”.
Ms McKay said she was staying solely as a tactical measure to maintain a family voice while her demand for an independent review was addressed.
"I am not walking away from Tuam. I am refusing to pretend that a seat at the table is the same as having a voice at it," she said.
A series of questions were put to Dr Brian Farrell via email on two occasions; he did not respond.




