'We have a crisis': Dáil committee makes 52 recommendations to improve road safety after 162 deaths
Oireachtas committee called for a new graduated penalty point system to 'reflect the severity of the driving offence'. File picture
The families of those who lose their lives in road traffic collisions are being “destroyed” and “living a nightmare” following their deaths, one bereft mother has said.
It came as the Oireachtas Transport Committee launched a wide-ranging report on road safety, calling for the establishment of an independent road safety commissioner, greater penalties for those who drive the wrong way down a motorway, and a new graduated penalty point system.
The committee’s chairperson, Michael Murphy, told the launch of the report that with 162 road deaths so far this year, “we have a crisis”.
Joanne McLaughlin spoke of the heartache caused to her family following her daughter and granddaughter’s deaths.
Natalie McLaughlin, a 27-year-old nurse, and her daughter Ella, who had just turned six, were killed in a crash in Donegal in July 2025.
Her partner, Tyrone, and their 18-month-old daughter Rhea-Rose sustained serious injuries in the crash. No other injuries were reported.
Lochlainn Doherty, 19, was charged with dangerous driving following the crash, and the case is currently before the courts.
“We are destroyed as a family. A baby and a mother were killed,” Joanne McLaughlin said.
“Another baby is left without her mother and sister. It's complete devastation to our family.
“[For] my daughter, my granddaughter, it was a normal day for them. She worked as a practice nurse, finished work, picked up my granddaughter, and was going off the road before her life ended.
“It was terrible. I can't describe what a nightmare we're in, and it is a nightmare. It's not a reality to us yet.”
The Oireachtas committee’s report contains 52 recommendations to improve safety on Irish roads.
It notes since 2019, road deaths have increased in Ireland by 31%, while falling by 15% in Europe.
The first recommendation calls for the establishment of an independent road safety commissioner.
The committee wants the strength of the Garda traffic corps returned to 2009 levels over the lifetime of the Government. There are currently 660 traffic gardaí, down from more than 1,000 in 2009.
It also called for a new graduated penalty point system to “reflect the severity of the driving offence”. This is despite the Government proposing this previously in 2024 and not following through on it.
The committee suggested the departments of justice and transport should examine the introduction of a new “aggregated offence of dangerous driving where a person deliberately travels the wrong way on a motorway, with much stronger custodial sentences”. However, Mr Murphy said the committee was not saying how long these prison sentences should be.
Other recommendations include introducing motorway and rural road driving experience as part of a learner driver’s essential driver training, considering introducing supervised driving experience for novice drivers, and progressing the alcohol ignition lock programme.
It also contained recommendations for increasing the maximum sentence for dangerous driving causing death or serious bodily injury from 10 to 14 years, and for driving disqualification periods to start once a person is released from prison.
The committee also called for penalties for driving under the “combined influence of alcohol and drugs” to be reviewed to “reflect the increased risk”.




