Referee Seán Stack: 'The two hand-passes rule is super, it really moves things on in the game'

Other rules on trial include the requirement for puck-outs to cross the 45m line, with three players from each team remaining between the 20m and 45m lines, the six steps allowance, two points for a sideline ball struck over the bar and the directive that 65s are taken from the attacking team's own half
Referee Sean Stack calls implemeting rules 'a pleasure'. Pic: Tom O'Hanlon/Inpho

Referee Sean Stack calls implemeting rules 'a pleasure'. Pic: Tom O'Hanlon/Inpho

Leading hurling referee Seán Stack says the trial rules are a pleasure to implement but has agreed with Head of Hurling Willie Maher that further analysis is required.

The Dublin based Sixmilebridge man took charge of Fitzgibbon Cup holders UL's surprise Division 1 league quarter-final loss to DCU on Wednesday evening.

The third-level league is being used as a vehicle to trial the suite of rules enhancements recommended by the Hurling Expert Advisory Group.

UL conceded three frees in the first 22 minutes on Wednesday for failing to display clear separation between the ball and the hand when executing a hand-pass.

They were also punished when DCU pointed from a free that was awarded for consecutive hand-passes, which aren't permitted under the trial.

But Stack, who took charge of June's All-Ireland SHC quarter-final between Cork and Offaly, as well as the Dublin hurling final, noted that hand-pass infringements reduced significantly as the game wore on.

Other rules on trial include the requirement for puck-outs to cross the 45m line, with three players from each team remaining between the 20m and 45m lines, the six steps allowance, two points for a sideline ball struck over the bar and the directive that 65s are taken from the attacking team's own half.

National Head of Hurling, and HEAG member, Willie Maher has stated that more time is needed to assess the rules and that '12 games is not enough', with speculation that further trials could take place during January's pre-season competitions for county teams.

GAA National Head of Hurling William Maher says more time is needed to assess the rules. Pic: Piaras Ó Mídheach/Sportsfile
GAA National Head of Hurling William Maher says more time is needed to assess the rules. Pic: Piaras Ó Mídheach/Sportsfile

"Inside in the game, as it's running, the game is definitely moving very good," said Stack after DCU's 2-21 to 1-20 defeat of UL. "The players want to use the stick-pass first of all which definitely moves things along. There probably were less rucks. As the game develops and lads get tired, that changes a little.

"But the two hand-passes rule I think is super, it really moves things on in the game. There are a few things that are difficult from an officiating point of view but in terms of the game, in open play, it's definitely a pleasure to officiate.

"Overall, I think there's a real positivity there. I saw Willie Maher came out the other day and said that 12 (third level) games probably isn't enough of a sample, I'd be inclined to agree with him there. I'd also like to see them work through the levels as well.

"I think there's a lot of positives and, as with any trial, a lot to keep an eye on to see how it develops. Trying it out at club level, potentially, and definitely at inter-county level, and seeing how it is implemented there is probably needed before you can make any sort of judgement.

"There's a lot that was positive, from my perspective. From an officiating point of view, there's a couple that if you want to implement the rules correctly, then it takes a level of focus. I wouldn't say that's a negative, it's just something that we'll have to get used to if they come in."

The requirement around puck-outs travelling beyond the 45m line, and at least six players - three from each team - remaining between the 20m and 45m lines while the puck-out is being taken, has generated debate.

From Stack's perspective, ensuring that both teams are keeping at least three players in that zone for every puck-out has been challenging.

"It's the dual task of scorekeeping and also doing that, in the one period," said Stack. "Because, number one, you're trying to make sure you get the score noted, and then you're also trying to do the count of players. It's hard to do that in the flow of the game."

Clare great Podge Collins, who has taken over as Mary Immaculate College Limerick manager, said after Tuesday's quarter-final win over Maynooth that the puck-out directive is leading to bunching around the middle, with opposition half-forward lines dropping off. Collins said they can do this as puck-outs to half-backs are now more difficult to execute as opposition forwards are lining themselves up on the 45m line.

"It will be interesting to see that develop," said Stack. "It was good tonight and you could see the two teams being very tactical in how they were swapping players in and out, so that they were always covered with the six. From the officiating side of things, that's when you really need your line umpires on the ball with you. The man in the middle can't have eyes everywhere."

Early analysis of the trials in Division 1 third-level games has found a reduction in rucks and more puck-out contests, as well as the anticipated spike in stick-passing. None of the trials will come into play in next year's National League or Championship.

Check out the entire podcast series HERE as, and when, they are published.

More in this section

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited