Seán Rooney inquest: Corporal was 'frustrated' with commander for leaving their vehicle behind

The inquest into Private Seán Rooney's death heard that five calls ensued between Capt. Kelly and Cpl Phelan after Pte Rooney's vehicle had become separated from the lead vehicle in hostile Lebanese territory.

The inquest into Private Seán Rooney's death heard that five calls ensued between Capt. Kelly and Cpl Phelan after Pte Rooney's vehicle had become separated from the lead vehicle in hostile Lebanese territory.

The soldier in command of an armoured vehicle in which Private Seán Rooney was shot dead said he felt angry with his commanding officer for leaving their vehicle behind.

Corporal Josh Phelan told an inquest into the death of Pte Rooney that he had felt frustrated with his commander Captain David Kelly after their convoy became separated in hostile Lebanese territory on the night of December 14, 2022.

Asked by Sean Guerin SC for Pte Rooney's family if he had been angry with Captain Kelly, Cpl Phelan told Dublin District Coroners' Court that "I just remember being frustrated". "That he was gone essentially," he added.

On the night in question the vehicle containing driver Pte Rooney, Cpl Phelan, and Troopers Shane Kearney and Nathan Bryan, became separated from the first vehicle in the two-vehicle convoy containing Captain Kelly at a mandatory stop at the Litani River.

With the first car disappearing from sight the second vehicle had continued along a minor road into the village of Aaqbiyeh, missing a turn-off for the main coastal highway which was to bring the convoy to Beirut's airport.

Corporal Phelan told the inquest that he "wasn't familiar at all" with the route the car was due to take through hostile territory before it became lost. He said that Captain Kelly was "extremely familiar" with the route as he had "gone through the route I don't know how many times".

The corporal was on his first tour of duty in Lebanon and had only arrived one month previously. He said that no formal briefing — which would normally last close to an hour — had been held in advance of the ad hoc mission, which had been laid on to drop Tpr Kearney and one other soldier to a flight to Ireland to attend separate funerals.

He said a very short briefing, less than 10 minutes and potentially less than five minutes, took place at the armoured cars before they were due to depart Camp Shamrock that evening.

He said that briefing was dominated by other soldiers saying their goodbyes to their departing colleagues and said he could not recall an instruction to make the turn at a garage, and could only remember "codewords for roads, Alpha 1, 'move on to Alpha 2'".

He agreed that the convoy was under time pressure in order to reach the airport in time for the departing soldiers' flights.

Cpl Phelan, who appeared deeply distressed throughout much of his evidence, said he had likewise had no formal training regarding Denial of Freedom of Movement (DFOM) incidents, four of which his car would endure via a hostile crowd of more than 50 people when driving back through Aaqbiyeh in an attempt to relocate their lead car before their boot and back window was breached and Pte Rooney was shot dead.

"My understanding was that generally it's teenagers (involved in a DFOM), they're bored, making a name for themselves, and that they'd last no longer than 15 to 20 minutes," he said.

Contact between vehicles

He agreed with Mr Guerin that the first indication his vehicle had gone astray was when he realised that they should have caught up with the first vehicle after several minutes of driving at high speed in an attempt to catch up.

The inquest heard that five calls ensued between Capt. Kelly and Cpl Phelan — two in quick succession at 10.50pm and 10.54pm from Capt. Kelly during which he instructed Cpl Phelan to turn the vehicle around and proceed back through Aaqbiyeh and to meet the first vehicle at the junction they had missed, where it would be waiting with its hazard lights on.

Cpl Phelan subsequently called Capt. Kelly at 11.06pm and 11.10pm at which point the vehicle had been stopped by a blockade of vehicles and a hostile crowd.

The final call between the two was made by Capt. Kelly at 11.16pm, at which point Cpl Phelan was no longer speaking directly to the other officer and had placed his phone on his lap as the crowd laid siege to the vehicle.

Regarding the call he had made to Capt. Kelly at 11.06pm when the DFOM was turning increasingly violent, Cpl Phelan said: "I thought he would make contact faster".

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited