Exempt migrants with Irish citizen in family from proposed residency rule, says McDowell
Independent senator Michael McDowell cautioned that he did not believe anybody who resides in Ireland should have 'an expectation' of citizenship. Picture: Brian Lawless/PA
People who are raising a family with an Irish citizen should be given exemptions from new residency rules for gaining citizenship, the Seanad has heard.
Independent senator Michael McDowell made the call for an exemption to be introduced to stop people from being required to wait eight years for citizenship, if they are raising a family alongside an Irish citizen.
Under newly proposed rules, the residency requirements for those seeking citizenship will increase to eight years, rising from five.
“There could be injustice in saying: "Sorry, but your plans are going to have to change" because we are going to demand that in addition to membership of this family and co-parenting with an Irish citizen, they will have to wait for another three years, or whatever it is, to become a citizen on top of satisfying the language qualification,” Mr McDowell said.
Read More
The new rules, announced by justice minister Jim O’Callaghan, include a language proficiency test in English, Irish, or Irish Sign Language.
People will also be required to demonstrate a “knowledge and understanding of Irish civics”, including society and politics, to a certain standard.
Mr McDowell said he did not accept the suggestion that the residency requirement was “set in stone”, and he warned of “injustices” for families where an individual is denied citizenship “unnecessarily on the basis of this change”.
The senator said he did not believe anybody who resides in Ireland should have “an expectation” of citizenship, saying it should be an expression of loyalty to the State.
“The idea of saying: "I have been here five years, give me citizenship", is completely misconceived,” he said.
In response, junior migration minister Colm Brophy said people having automatic rights to citizenship just because they work in Ireland was “not an idea I support”.
“Citizenship is a privilege,” he said. "It is something people must value, and they must have that as part of a process that is fair to them and to the State."
Social Democrats senator Patricia Stephenson said she was concerned about the fact that some migrants to Ireland feel they have had “the rug pulled out from underneath them” with the Government’s changes.
“They have been living here and have been contributing. In some instances, they might have married Irish people, but even if they have not married Irish people, their kids might be in school, and they want to build lives here,” Ms Stephenson said.
“They are contributing to our economy and to our communities.
“I worry that we are creating a double-edged sword with this, and I hope that will be discussed in the pre-legislative scrutiny. We are actually disincentivising people whom we need in our economy and in our labour market, and that is a concern.”




