'Number eights like number one' says Farrell after more injury worry
Ireland's James McNabney is pursued by Fiji's Kitione Salawa and Ben Volavola. Pic: INPHO/Ben Brady
Ireland’s back row to face South Africa at Aviva Stadium this Saturday may be self-selecting after Andy Farrell’s squad sustained yet another injury at No.8 in their 43-15 Nations Championship win over Fiji.
James McNabney’s impactful debut off the bench as a second-half replacement for starting No.8 Nick Timoney was cut short after less than four power-packed minutes, the concussion he received from direct head contact from the forearm of Fijian prop Inoke Ravuiwasa initiating an immediate 12-day stand-down for the 23-year-old Ulsterman to complete his return to play protocols.
Timoney, making his first start for Ireland in the position a week on from a star turn in his more familiar berth at openside flanker, returned to the field on 53 minutes and scored his side’s seventh and final try with a big carry over the line. With McNabney now joining fellow No.8s Caelan Doris, Jack Conan, Bryn Ward and Sean Jansen on the sidelines, it is Timoney who looks set to continue in the role for the final round-robin fixture of this fledgling competition.
Connacht captain Cian Prendergast is also in the squad but has had no game time this month while the uncapped David McCann, yet another Ulster back-row, has been training with the senior squad since his call-up following Jansen’s knee injury against Argentina on November 6.
Timoney, 31, started that game alongside Jansen and blindside flanker Ryan Baird having been preferred to regular starter at number seven Josh van Flier, who impressed head coach Farrell on his return to the jersey against the Fijians, as did the auxiliary No.8.
“Good, good. It was good to see him on the field,” Farrell said of Timoney. “I thought Josh was excellent today. Every time he had a carry, I thought the Fijians were knocking most people back but not Josh.
“I thought he was excellent, so he stood up to Nick’s performance last week so we have a job to do in selection.
“Obviously James coming on and what he did would have been in the forefront of our minds as well but that’s not to be. Yeah, number eights like number one at the minute, isn’t it? Anyway, that’s life.”
Ireland do expect hooker Dan Sheehan to be available to face the Springboks following his 12 days' lay-off for a concussion against Argentina, and he would be a wild card selection for the No.8 role having started there for Leinster against Munster last month, yet Timoney looks like featuring in the back row at No.8 alongside flanker Baird and van der Flier this Saturday afternoon.
Farrell reported McNabney to be in good health post-match but agreed his loss for this weekend was a pity.
“He was in our thoughts 100 per cent in regards to next week,” the Ireland boss said.
“He's joking in the changing rooms. He's delighted with himself for the shortest cameo of a first cap. I reckon it's the best cameo of three-and-a-half minutes or whatever it was on a debut in Irish history really.
“He remembers the two breaks that he made, so he seems in good spirits.” McNabney may recover in time to return for a second cap on finals weekend in London on November 27-29, with replacement tighthead prop Sam Illo also going through the Head Injury Assessment process and potentially on a similar timeline as the back rower.
Jamie Osborne’s prognosis, delivered by Farrell on Saturday night, and ahead of medical confirmation, was much bleaker, however. Named at outside centre for his first start of the month, Osborne’s night was ended in the fourth minute after an injury to his chest.
“Yeah, poor lad. It looks like a pec muscle, so that doesn't look too good when he's coming off after the first contact. They got into the hole just on the outside of him. His body wasn't behind him. I think he just reached out like that and felt it straight away, so not great for him.”
With Garry Ringrose playing no part this month following a hamstring injury, Ireland may return to Robbie Henshaw as their choice at 13 after his impressive performance there against Argentina in week one.




