Health service has employment ceiling not recruitment embargo, says official
Some committee members laughed with derision when department assistant secretary Bernard Carey made the admission.
Last week, the committee was told that St Vincent’s Hospital in Dublin was not allowed to hire desperately needed staff for cystic fibrosis (CF) services because of staff ceilings, even though Health Minister Mary Harney has said no such staff ceiling exists.
Fine Gael Health spokesman Dr Liam Twomey said that, whatever the restriction on recruitment was called, it was being used as an excuse to prevent the taking on of frontline staff in the health service.
Health Service Executive (HSE) assistant national director Fionnuala Duffy said €4.7 million was allocated by the department last year for services for people with CF and a further €2m this year.
Ms Duffy, who is responsible for planning and development in the HSE, said a lot more progress would be made this year and it was intended to create 57 CF staff positions across the country.
She also pointed out that discussions were taking place with the Department of Health on adjusting the employment ceiling to allow the appointment of the additional staff.
At an earlier meeting of the committee, chief executive of the Cystic Fibrosis Association of Ireland Godfrey Fletcher said all hospitals had been told by the HSE that, in order to implement the CF plan, each would have to achieve financial break-even for the year and comply with staff ceiling controls.
Earlier, Mr Carey said that in December last year the department informed the HSE the ceiling on recruitment was being lifted so that the number of full-time staff in the health service could be increased by 10,450 to 108,000.
HSE national director Tommy Martin told the committee that the average time taken to approve consultant posts was two months, a claim which was later disputed by the secretary general of the Irish Hospital Consultants’ Association (IHCA) Finbarr Fitzpatrick.
“It is our experience that appointments take far longer than two months. They get stuck in the HSE’s National Hospital’s Office,” said Mr Fitzpatrick.
Mr Martin said only about 10% of applications can be delayed for significant periods but Ms Fitzpatrick claimed the figure was far greater than that.




