Irish food producers need to capitalise on a new type of currency: Attention
From left: Director of Food and Drink Ireland at Ibec, Paul Kelly; insight and expert community manager at Our Food Roots, Richard Cooper; director of Consumer Ireland at Tirlán, Mandy Hennebry; and dietitian at Tallaght University Hospital, Jack Boland, with MC Helen Carroll discussing ‘Beyond the Farm Gate: Understanding Tomorrow's Consumer’, hosted by Nuffield Ireland.
Irish food producers must compete in an "attention economy" dominated by influencers and social media personalities if they want to remain relevant to consumers, a conference has heard.
Speaking during a panel discussion, ‘Beyond the Farm Gate: Understanding Tomorrow's Consumer’, hosted by Nuffield Ireland, insight and expert community manager at Our Food Roots Richard Cooper, said: "We are living in the attention economy… The two currencies that are highest value in the attention economy are relevance and credibility."
Panellists said consumers were increasingly influenced by social media platforms, including TikTok Shop, creating both opportunities and challenges for food producers.
The panel featured Mr Cooper, director of Consumer Ireland at Tirlán, Mandy Hennebry, director of Food and Drink Ireland at Ibec Paul Kelly, and a Coru-accredited dietitian at Tallaght University Hospital, Jack Boland.
Read More
The panel repeatedly linked influencer marketing with concerns about trust and credibility, a fundamental foundation of traditional marketing and advertising.
"One challenge is both in terms of whether you can actually trust the integrity of the information… it's quite sort of an unregulated area in some respects, although there is legislation there, which we will cover in some of the digital legislation, but certainly it's a growing area," Mr Kelly said.
Mr Boland warned of the dangers of taking internet claims at face value, reminding attendees “anyone in Europe can call themselves a nutritionist”, and promoting products was a job for some influencers, usually with payment or affiliation involved, and in some cases could be an influencer's “sole income.”
“There's a lot of noise around nutrition… They're trying to sell you something. There is going to be the affiliation with certain companies, and where there's money to be made, unfortunately, it's not always someone's best outcome from a lifestyle point of view,” he said.
Mr Boland referenced a DCU study, recently published, that analysed posts on social media regarding food or food product promotion, which found “over 98% of the nearly 70,000 posts they analysed had misinformation on it”.
Also commenting on the dangers of misinformation, Ms Hennebry explained for large retailers, sometimes fighting misinformation could actually worsen a problem and draw more attention to a situation, incurring a negative effect on a brand or product.
"If there's misinformation online, though, there usually is no point in going to battle over it. We may just refuse something and leave it at that because you're only giving petrol to a fire sometimes when you get involved in these kinds of discussions."
The panel also noted social media could create significant opportunities for food companies.
Ms Hennebry referenced a time when it benefited Tirlán, offering the anecdote of Andrew Porter posting a picture of his shopping basket which contained Tirlán-owned products, boosting sales despite no affiliation to the brand, just consumer preference documented on a public platform.
"We weren't paying him, and just the amount of chatter around it and the amount of demand placed on that product by having him show it in his shopping basket... so we try and capitalise on the positives because there's no point in getting into it, unless something is completely false"
In discussions on consumer interests, sustainability was revealed to be an expectation rather than a praised achievement from customers.
Manufacturers are no longer getting a "pat on the back" from consumers for environmentally sustainable practices, Ms Hennebry explained.
Ms Hennebry described sustainability as a "hygiene factor" for consumers, saying they expect good environmental standards but are unwilling to pay significantly more for them.
"They do care, but they're certainly not going to fork out a lot of extra money to pay for something because it's more environmentally friendly," Ms Hennebry said, arguing consumers now expect everyone in the value chain to be addressing sustainability.
However, Mr Kelly said consumers still believed sustainability to be important and Irish food and drink was grounded in sustainability.
"No, I think it remains as important, if not more important. It's part of that value proposition… The systems we have here and the story we're telling is very much grounded in the sustainability credentials as well," he said.
"They expect the supplier, the retailer, all along the value chain to do that for them," Ms Hennebry said.
A similar sentiment was raised by Mr Cooper, saying although consumers rate sustainability and sustainable practices as very important, it was not the biggest influence when it comes to the weekly shop, where price and convenience often outweigh environmental concerns.
"It's not to say that these citizen issues aren't important. It's just that we're seeing that they're being superseded by these consumer issues… "The consumer today abhors paying more for food in this climate of food price inflation."
With the rise of GLP-1 medication and other weight-loss drugs, consumer habits have begun to shift, creating new opportunities for Irish food producers.
Ms Hennebry highlighted consumers were not necessarily buying less food, but pivoting purchasing habits.
"They're not necessarily buying, spending that much less on food; they're just switching what they're buying."
Mr Kelly said: "Certain food categories are seeing declines in the US, up to high single digits, low double-digit numbers… Dairy, protein, red meats and fresh fruit are seeing significant increases."
Mr Boland told conference attendees: "In layman's terms, it's [GLP-1s] there to regulate someone's appetite," and is used to treat obesity. However, he said takers of the medications did not need to stray far from the food pyramid to ensure positive results.
"We don't really have to reinvent the wheel when it comes to nutrition and GLP-1s," Mr Boland said, with Mr Cooper adding with the medication and consumers' interest in dairy and red meats, these sectors are well positioned to lean into the growth of interest.
"Dairy and beef are particularly well positioned to capitalise on the growth trend of GLP-1… Success and growth in this area depends on us recognising the genuine consumer need, listening to them, seeing what they want and then innovating around this," Mr Cooper said.





