Rassie Erasmus says Sam Prendergast tackle deserved red but expects him to face South Africa

Erasmus questioned officiating and disciplinary consistency ahead of South Africa's clash with Ireland
Rassie Erasmus believes Ireland out-half Sam Prendergast will be available to face South Africa due to a 'technicality'. Pic: ©INPHO/Tom O'Hanlon

Rassie Erasmus believes Ireland out-half Sam Prendergast will be available to face South Africa due to a 'technicality'. Pic: ©INPHO/Tom O'Hanlon

Rassie Erasmus arrived in Dublin on Saturday. He landed with a bang on Monday afternoon.

The South African head coach has asked serious questions about the nature of the officiating in their game against France in Paris, and in the Ireland-Fiji tie in Dublin the following day, with the role of both TMOs falling squarely in his sights.

He has also stated that Sam Prendergast should have seen red for his tackle on Fiji’s Peceli Yato at the weekend, but added that the playmaker will probably face no punishment due to a technicality despite being cited for the incident on Monday.

That second point he linked to Tadhg Furlong’s disciplinary process when the tighthead was unanimously cleared of an allegation that he had grabbed the groin of Munster’s Gavin Coombes while playing for Leinster last month.

It was an extraordinary press conference at the Springbok team hotel at the start of a week when they face Andy Farrell’s side in the Aviva Stadium, and it remains to be seen if any of his words land him in hot water with officialdom again.

Erasmus had already shared his thoughts on the Bok team he had named for that game, Ireland’s strengths, his past experiences in Dublin and the vital scrum battle, before Prendergast’s citing was raised and things got really interesting.

The Ireland No.10 has been cited for the alleged hip-drop challenge on Yato during Saturday’s 43-15 win. Such tackles are illegal as of this month’s Nations Championship window but the incident was not addressed by the referee or TMO at the time.

“I am going to say the right words now,” said Erasmus when asked how the Irish challenge would change if the Leinster player was not available. “We are in the northern hemisphere. I think there is going to be a technicality and he is going to play.” 

The follow-up question was inevitable. What did he mean by a technicality?

“It’s Monday. It’s now in the papers. Was it within the period, the 12-hour period? Who cited him? When was it cited? When Jasper (Wiese) got cited, it was six hours after the (France) game, we got the papers.

“Northern hemisphere, he’ll probably get cited for 2-3 weeks so won’t play in the next two games and then he’ll probably be available, we’ll get that release. In my experience from when we’re here, it’s… I’m not 100% sure how it works.

“I’m not a legal guy, I don’t have the right to say anything on it. I don’t have a pleasant experience here from going through Lood de Jager, Jan Hendrik Wessels, Franco Mostert, other things. It never seems to go our way.

“I’m not saying anybody’s doing anything wrong. I’m just not expecting him to get…. I think he’ll play on Saturday. (It’s) like Tadhg (Furlong). Tadhg got free, did the same thing Jan-Hendrik did.

“I don’t want to go into details because I’m not a legal person but from a South African point of view, that hurt. We felt it’s more or less the same situation and Jan Hendrik got nine weeks, the other guy got free.” 

Erasmus had posted a cryptic tweet in the wake of that Furlong decision but claimed here that it was absolutely not related to the URC’s disciplinary decision at the time. However, he did ask how it was different to the ban previously handed to Jan-Hendrik Wessels.

The South Africa front-row had been handed a nine-match suspension for grabbing Josh Murphy's genitals in the Bulls' United Rugby Championship win over Connacht just over 12 months ago.

“One guy got nine weeks. It cost him 1.5 million rand. He didn’t play for the Springboks, didn’t get the pay, and the other guy played the next weekend. That’s all I’m saying.

“And I’m not saying who’s right and who’s wrong, I’m saying the optics of that. If you don’t explain it clearly to the public and put it out there, that this is the difference between the two, none of us would understand it.

“I’m really not moaning. I’m telling you how I feel when you ask me will Prendergast play. I think he will because our history of what we see in these cases, and maybe we just don’t have the expert on the legal side.” 

The tone of the back-and-forth was set now and it was Erasmus who expanded the topic further by sharing his experiences of a three-hour World Rugby coaches’ meeting some weeks ago where the hip-drop tackle and its introduction was discussed.

The Prendergast tackle on Yato, who went off injured shortly after, was described as “terrible” and Erasmus said plainly that it was a clear red card offence. He also claimed that there were 17 knee-drop tackles committed against the Boks by France in Saint-Denis.

Eleven of them, he said, were penalties at least. Three or four were yellow cards minimum. None were addressed by the officials.

Erasmus has been in trouble with rugby authorities before. He was suspended for ten months following his criticisms of officials during the British and Irish Lions 2021 series, and he was mindful of that when saying he would be in trouble if he sent any video clips.

The role of the TMO has become a bugbear in rugby. The France-South Africa game stretched beyond two hours but Erasmus claims there is a drive in the game globally right now to reduce its fingerprint on proceedings.

He is not a fan of this, or the fact that the TMO did not pick up one of those 17 tackles.

“I’m not saying he’s wrong, I’m saying if he didn’t see it, it must be a technology problem. If he saw it and decided not to act on it, is that not interfering with the outcome of a game if you see this injury that happened there, a knee-drop tackle happened there, and it’s been decided that knee drop tackles are out.

“On numerous times we mentioned to the referee, ‘we think there’s (been) a knee drop tackle’. I’m saying to you my feeling is that knee drop tackles is out. They happened 17 times in our game. Not one was penalised.

“And if the TMO didn’t see it, then maybe technology must be better. If he saw it and ignored it, what does that boil down to?  

“So, all I’m asking is don’t take the TMOs out and dis-encourage them to get involved. Then the wrong team will win and players will get injured. That’s all I’m saying.” 

This was “not an accusation”, he insisted.

Erasmus knows how to handle the media, and he will be accused of manipulating the narrative from the off this week, but he did make the point that the belated citing for Prendergast doesn’t really suit Ireland either as they plan for Saturday.

Erasmus has named a fully locked and loaded XV and squad for the Ireland game with Eben Etzebeth back in the second row after his recent injury issues. And they ship up with the pain of that defeat in Paris still in their system.

Andy Farrell has spoken about wanting to face the best eleven months out from the next World Cup. His counterpart smiled and joked when asked if he felt the same.

“No, we would like them not to be at their best. We would like them to beat them. Look, we've never been out there and saying we're the world's best. On the rankings, we're pretty okay, but we lose two, three matches a year.

“We lost to Australia, the previous year we lost to Argentina. We try sometimes a few things, and me personally and us as a team have never said, ‘listen, we don't make mistakes and we don't pick wrong teams and we don't have the right game plan’. We don't say those things.”

SOUTH AFRICA: Damian Willemse; Kurt-Lee Arendse, Jesse Kriel, Damian de Allende, Ethan Hooker; Sacha Feinberg-Mngomezulu Morne van den Berg; Cameron Hanekom, Pieter-Steph du Toit, Siya Kolisi (captain); Ruan Nortje, Eben Etzebeth; Wilco Louw, Malcolm Marx, Ox Nche.

Replacements: Jan-Hendrik Wessels, Gerhard Steenekamp, Thomas du Toit, Lood de Jager, Paul de Villiers, Marco van Staden, Grant Williams, Canan Moodie

More in this section

Sport

Newsletter

Sign up to our daily sports bulletin, delivered straight to your inbox at 5pm. Subscribers also receive an exclusive email from our sports desk editors every Friday evening looking forward to the weekend's sporting action.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited