Watch Joe Schmidt give his view of Ireland's performance; player ratings

Joe Schmidt has said his Ireland side were "tested on a number of levels" today against Scotland.

Watch Joe Schmidt give his view of Ireland's performance; player ratings

Joe Schmidt has said his Ireland side were "tested on a number of levels" today against Scotland.

Ireland ended up as 28-22 winners in their warm-up at the Aviva Stadium this afternoon, but they looked lacklustre against a Scotland side that fought back impressively to nearly snatch a win at the death.

Hear Joe Schmidt's thoughts on the game below, and check out the player ratings from the game.



SIMON ZEBO: Mixed bag but always a threat in open-field action. 6/10

TOMMY BOWE: Physicality and size offers Ireland a key differential. 7

JARED PAYNE: Quiet enough but no clangers. 7

GORDON D’ARCY: Unable to impose himself in the style of old. 6

LUKE FITZGERALD: Took his try well but looked rusty elsewhere. 7

IAN MADIGAN: Late surge levelled out his day. 7

ISAAC BOSS: Still craves the tempo of Conor Murray. 6

DAVE KILCOYNE: Conceded too many penalties in the loose. 5

SEAN CRONIN: More errors than usual from the free-running hooker. 6

MIKE ROSS: Another powerful scrummaging effort. 8

DEVIN TONER: Solid without shining in his usual style. 7

DAN TUOHY: World Cup chances could be slim now. 6

JACK CONAN: Did not let anyone down on debut. 6

CHRIS HENRY: Outstanding over the ball, thwarted Scotland all day. 8

SEAN O’BRIEN (captain): Bullish effort at the base of the scrum. 7


RICHARDT STRAUSS (for Cronin, 59): Decent cameo. 7

MICHAEL BENT (for Kilcoyne, 59): Kept the scrum levels up. 6

NATHAN WHITE (for Ross, 53): One fine turnover underlined a solid debut. 7

PAUL O’CONNELL (for Tuohy, 55): Regular captain back with all the usual intensity. 7

JORDI MURPHY (for Conan, 64): Put himself about. 6

EOIN REDDAN (for Boss, 66): Tried to raise the tempo. 6

PADDY JACKSON (for Zebo, 77): Little action at the death. 6

DAVE KEARNEY (for Bowe, 59): Produced one neat break. 7


RUARIDH JACKSON: Started in an unfamiliar full-back role but used his handling skills to clever effect clever in the build-up to Blair Cowan’s score. 7/10

SEAN LAMONT: The veteran winger wants to complete a century of caps at the World Cup. A vintage display full of daring drives forward will put him in contention. 7

RICHIE VERNON: The former flanker became the first Scot in 137 years to have played in both the forward and back divisions but his conversion to centre looks a wise move. 6

PETER HORNE: An impressive display from the versatile back at centre. Could have done better with his goal-kicking but made amends with the third try. 7

TIM VISSER: Has all the tools but seldom makes the most of them for his adopted nation. 5

GREIG TONKS: The Edinburgh fly-half had little chance to make a dent on the Irish defences in the first half but did better after the break. 6

HENRY PYRGOS: Started the match as Scotland’ third choice scrum-half but will have given Vern Cotter food for thought after getting on the scoresheet. 7

RYAN GRANT: The prop’s World Cup hopes were left hanging by a thread when he was stretched off with an ankle injury. 5

FRASER BROWN: Started confidently but couple of loose throws put a stain on his first Scotland start. 5

JON WELSH: Let the Irish off the hook with a couple of untimely errors at the breakdown. Off with concussion after the break. 5

JIM HAMILTON: A lack of mobility and discipline has always been the lock’s main flaws and again they blighted an otherwise committed display. 5

GRANT GILCHRIST: Showed little rustiness after 10 months out with arm injuries. Should be heading to England. 7

BLAIR COWAN: Another impressive performance from the London Irish back-rower, capped off with his second Scotland try. 7

HUGH BLAKE: Scotland’s latest ’kilted Kiwi’ was under pressure to perform following his controversial call-up but proved why Cotter rates him so highly. 7

DAVID DENTON: A bright display from the Edinburgh man. Should have released the ball to Lamont though when the Scots were charging forward in the second half. 6


GORDON REID (for Grant, 45): Gave his side stability at the scrum. 5

MIKE CUSACK (for Welsh, 47): The English-born prop made his Scotland debut when Welsh had to be replaced following a head knock. 4

ROSS FORD (for Brown, 52): Battled away as the game grew stretched in the closing stages. 4

ROB HARLEY (for Hamilton, 56): Asked to beef up Scottish defence after Ireland’s second try. 4

JOHN BARCLAY (for Cowan, 59): Back after an 18-month exile from the Dark Blues set-up. 4

MATT SCOTT (for Vernon, 60): Made a couple of decent carries late on. 4

More in this section


Latest news from the world of sport, along with the best in opinion from our outstanding team of sports writers

Sign up

Select your favourite newsletters and get the best of Irish Examiner delivered to your inbox