'You don't have any right': Maher defends Thurles' record as Munster final awaits

Thurles Sarsfield have won 47 Tipperary SHC titles but just one Munster club. 
Thurles Sarsfields manager Pádraic Maher captained the club to their only Munster title in 2012. Pic: Ray McManus/Sportsfile

Thurles Sarsfields manager Pádraic Maher captained the club to their only Munster title in 2012. Pic: Ray McManus/Sportsfile

Pádraic Maher was obviously delighted after managing his club Thurles Sarsfields to the Munster club SHC final, but there remained one irksome topic: their record.

Sars, Tipperary’s bluebloods, who have 37 county titles to their name, have just one Munster club championship gong. Maher was captain in 2012 when they claimed it.

Now, it should be said the All-Ireland club championship has only been contested since 1970. Since then, Thurles have claimed 10 Tipperary SHC titles. Still, far from an amazing hit-rate.

The final question Maher faced in Zimmer Biomet Páirc Chíosóg on Sunday centred on this fact. It took extra-time to shake off Inagh-Kilnamona’s considerable challenge. Maher has faced that question in all kinds of guises over the years.

“Yeah, look, the club has been in the Munster club a nice bit for the last 15 years, but a bit of context: we have got over games by a puck of the ball, we have been bet in games by a puck of the ball or extra time,” he began.

“When people think of club hurling in the last 20 years, they will mention Ballygunner, they will mention Na Piarsaigh, do you know what I mean? They are the teams that were pipping us. Cratloe had a serious team here for a couple of years in Clare. We faced them when they had, I would say seven or eight lads in the Clare senior team. Na Piarsaigh beat us, we lost to Ballyea, we beat Ballygunner, we lost to Ballygunner after extra-time. There is nothing in it.” 

The margins. Thurles could just as easily have been on the wrong end of a one-score game as the right one. They were preparing for penalties when Robbie Stapleton slotted the late winner.

Thurles Sarsfields have competed in the Munster club championship nine times in the 21st century. They lost to the eventual champions four times and won it once. Of their eight losses, four were one-score games. They have been close, basically. It is not a case of not turning up.

“Just because we didn’t get over the line, people say, our record. To be honest with you, it does bother you if you don't get over the line, but you can’t… I mean, I look at it and say, right, you're playing (other champions), what do you expect? You don't have any right to come in and just, it's not like an intercounty championship where you might feel that you're ahead of someone else. Do you know what I mean?” 

In a competition as competitive as Munster hurling, there will always be talk about records. Last weekend meant Clare clubs haven’t won a Munster senior hurling title since 2016, an intermediate since 2015, and the last junior was in 2003. The poor fortunes of Cork clubs in the competition have been well-publicised in recent weeks.

The broader point, though, is the brutal reality of knockout club hurling at this time of year. On a day like Sunday, the only option was to dog it out. Hurling in November is so fundamentally different from what they would have played earlier this year. Sars played their first county championship group game at the end of July.

At its core, the only priority is finding a way to survive. Individual mistakes are costly. Maher referenced his own error when a sliotar slipped through his grasp in 2017 against Ballygunner. They went on to lose in extra-time.

That was what pleased him most about their display. They let a four-point lead slip, they missed some scoreable chances and coughed up cheap turnovers. Yet they found a way.

“You see it there: two teams that haven't played each other before, unknown. You can watch as many videos as you like, but when you come into the cut and thrust of it down here in November, you see it there and see how attritional it was; there was nothing in it. As I said, it just gives us another two weeks to stay alive.”

More in this section

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited