Maurice Brosnan: Thurles Sars dog it out in primal winter struggle
Inagh Kilnamona's David Mescall with Denis Maher of Thurles Sarsfields. Pic ©INPHO/Tom O'Hanlon
Eighty minutes in the foxhole. After a gruelling struggle, Robbie Stapleton’s last-gasp point finally decided it.
There were heroes on both sides. Aidan McCarthy finished with 11 points, Aidan McCormack with ten, in a contest that was only ever going to be settled by the slimmest margin. A crowd of 3,983 witnessed an extraordinary game that was far from flawless and yet all the more primal for it.
Before throw-in, the Zimmer Biomet Páirc Chíosóg PA announcer repeatedly urged management and subs to leave the field in preparation for the national anthem. Thurles Sarsfields left together and stood on the sideline; Inagh-Kilnamona ignored it completely and gathered in a huddle in the middle. In their own way, both were determined to present a united front.
Read More
It was a day of pure winter hurling. Every time the ball hit the turf, it died. David Mescall went down in front of the Aldi end goal with ridges of turf rising all around him. Both teams struggled to get to grips with the bitter crossfield wind, with free-takers Aidan McCarthy and Aidan McCormack both missing from scoreable range in the first half. Referee Thomas Walsh, who famously awarded just six first-half frees in the 2025 Munster hurling final, awarded 12 here, and one Conor Hegarty point came while he was playing advantage. The foul tally after 60 minutes ran past 20.
At one point in the second half, the crowd became enraptured by every lurch. In the imperfections, they found something to love. Turnover. Hit. Turnover. Slip. Turnover. Hit. HardHardHard. Éamonn Foudy breaking out from his goal. Ball dropped. Roar again. Chance gone. Euan Murray shot. Wide! Roar some more. That was all it was, the cold reality of it: a day to dog it out.
At half-time, it was 0-8 to 0-8. The Tipperary champions started better, with Kieran Rossiter’s diagonal runs providing a welcome outlet and Conor Stakelum enjoying plenty of possession from six. Seán Rynne hit two early points to ensure they never stretched away, before a McCarthy free put Inagh-Kilnamona ahead for the first time after 22 minutes.
It stayed nip-and-tuck. The travelling support thought they had a goal to cheer when a Stakelum free dropped short and Paddy Creedon swung, but the sliotar found the side netting. They did cheer, and heartily, when Ronan Maher came on early in the second half; the three-time All-Star broke his ankle in a challenge match last June. For a while, the tide looked to have turned. McCormack and Rossiter, along with a terrific score from sub Tommy Maher, pushed Thurles four clear.
Enter McCarthy. The 2024 All-Ireland winner and Inagh-Kilnamona captain landed his first point from play after 56 minutes and had three from play before Walsh blew for full-time with the scoreline reading 0-17 to 0-17. The last five points for the Clare champions all came from the number 14. Big days find big men.

By then, the toll was evident. So many calves were being stretched out. Sars manager Pádraic Maher ripped a flag out of the ground; such was his fury at one refereeing decision.
In extra-time, with his first possession, Stapleton fired over to put Thurles ahead. McCarthy once again produced a sublime response.
The long ball to Gearóid Barry was laid off to McCarthy, powering down the middle. Keith Loughnane had done a fine job on him early on, but by this point Seosamh Ryan was giving chase. McCarthy shook him off and sprinted past Denis Maher, who stuck a hurl across and fouled him. Playing the advantage, the captain pointed to level it again.
Inagh-Kilnamona could never get back in front. The margin at the extra-time break was one. A long-range free from goalkeeper Éamonn Foudy, his second, left it all square again. As the board went up for one additional minute, Sars tried to make one final change. Pa Bourke jumped up, togged and ready. Their management raced up the line to urge Denis Maher to slow down over a free, but it was too late. He went long, Stapleton won the break and iced it.
It was both a glorious end and a cruel one. The Clare champions showed huge heart to fight back from four down. Sars showed unbreakable spirit to see it out. Since Thurles last won the Munster club hurling championship in 2012, Ballygunner have been in nine finals. Another day in the trenches awaits.
A. McCarthy 0-11 (7f); C. Hegarty, S. Rynne 0-3 each; E. Foudy (2f), D. Fitzgerald 0-2 each; J. Guyler 0-1.
A. McCormack 0-10 (3f); K. Rossiter 0-4; R. Stapleton 0-3; A. Stakelum 0-2; K. Loughnane, E. Murray, D. Rossiter, T. Maher 0-1 each.
E. Foudy; K. White, S. Woods, C. Rynne; K. Hehir, J. Hegarty, D. Cullinan; M. Callinan, S. Rynne; D. Fitzgerald, K. Guyler, F. Hegarty; D. Mescall, A. McCarthy, C. Hegarty.
G. Barry for Mescall (36); N. Mullins for Guyler (47); J. McCarthy for F. Hegarty (56); J. Guyler for C. Hegarty (58); J. Mescall for Callinan (60) C. Hegarty for Barry (65); F. Hegarty for J. Mescall (70); C. Ryan for White (70); B. Foudy for Cullinan (78).
P. McCormack; P. Maher, D. Maher, S. Maher; K. Loughnane, Conor Stakelum, Cian Stakelum; D. Rossiter, A. Stakelum; E. Purcell, A. McCormack, E. Murray; D. Stakelum, P. Creedon, K. Rossiter.
Subs: R. Maher for Purcell (38); T. Maher for Creedon (52); S. Ryan for S. Maher (60). J. Armstrong for C. Stakelum, R. Stapleton for Rossiter (both 60); E. Purcell for D. Stakelum (76).
T. Walsh (Modeligo).



