Letters to the Editor: Ireland must work for justice for Palestinians

Ireland can still be a stellar member of the European club by preserving its own military neutrality, providing its own defence, and pressing for non-war solutions to disputes
Johnny McEvoy, pictured performing in 2019, who died recently.

Johnny McEvoy, pictured performing in 2019, who died recently.

What a national treasure Michael D is: Our iar-uachtarán is a wonderful example of the value of having an office of president above the fray of party politics. He is willing to speak out and remind politicians of our national values and our representatives’ obligation to present these values before the councils and assemblies of the world — including the European Union and the United Nations.

The EU has been taken captive by the militarism that is sweeping Europe. Those EU members that are members of Nato seem to have taken over the European enterprise and are making the EU into a subset of Nato. In such a militaristic frenzy, it is tempting for Irish politicians to wish to abandon neutrality and to pursue the path of militarism, gaining in popularity in the European halls of power. But in resisting that temptation, Ireland can still be a stellar member of the European club by preserving its own military neutrality, providing its own defence, and pressing for non-war solutions to disputes.

The great moral challenge of our time is the horrific suffering imposed on the Palestinian people by Israel. Will Europe do anything? Other than earnest posturing and stylised hand-wringing and the citing of geopolitical complexities, no, it’s best not to expect Europe will do anything effective. The answer on Palestine is the same answer given to the horrific abandonment by Europe of the boys and men of Bosnia, lined up and taken away to be killed by Serbians.

The reality is that some EU member states are pre-committed to support the state of Israel in whatever it does: irrespective of how unjustly it treats Palestinians, irrespective of how many Palestinian civilians it kills or the children it maims, or the schools and hospitals it bombs. We have seen more examples of this support for Israel in its recent attacks on Lebanon, Iran, and Syria. With such unconditional support of Israel we cannot rely on Israel’s allies to ensure justice and freedom for the Palestinian people.

Israel has declared clearly that it will not voluntarily agree to the Palestinian people having their own state. But nothing less than internationally recognised self-determination will protect Palestinians. If Ireland’s history truly displays a national values commitment to freedom and self-determination, then Ireland, even if alone of EU members, can have a noble role in demanding and effecting positive permanent change in the woeful condition of the Palestinian people.

However, we must do this not needing and expecting applause and admiration but, do it because it is the right thing to do. For a little while, Ireland has a voice in the affairs of the world. Let’s use it for good. The awful slaughter and dehumanising treatment of the Palestinian people by Israel cries out for a remedy that is peaceful and permanent. Europe missed out on saving the boys and men of Bosnia in 1995. Europe has missed out on stopping the slaughter of some 74,000 Palestinians by Israel over recent years. Let us not miss out again now on stopping the genocide and ethnic cleansing of Palestinians. Ireland must work to stop this killing by working loudly and persistently for an independent Palestinian state.

Aodan MacTomais, Maigh Chromtha, Corcaigh


Remembering the magic of McEvoy

The passing of Johnny McEvoy brought back a rather special memory of an encounter I had with him in West Cork in 2017.

Johnny had just finished performing at a wonderfully intimate gig in the Four Alls pub. Afterwards, I had the opportunity to speak with him, and I asked him a question about his haunting song commemorating Michael Collins.

Why, I wondered, had he chosen the curlew for the song’s introduction? Johnny told me that, remarkably, nobody had ever asked him that question before.

He then shared a story that has stayed with me ever since.

Some years earlier, while travelling through the Comeragh Mountains in Co Waterford, he had pulled over to rest. In the stillness of the mountains, he heard the distant call of a curlew.

He described it as the loneliest sound he had ever heard.

The experience had made such an impression on him that, when composing his song about Michael Collins, he drew upon that memory to create its haunting opening.

It was a brief conversation, but a memorable one. What struck me was how something so simple, a solitary bird calling across an Irish mountainside, could inspire such a moving piece of music.

Johnny McEvoy had an extraordinary gift for capturing the beauty, sorrow, and humanity of the Irish experience. That evening, I was fortunate enough to glimpse something of the creative imagination behind that gift.

Nine years have passed since our conversation, yet I remember it with remarkable clarity.

Perhaps that was McEvoy’s greatest gift: his ability to recognise something extraordinary in the most ordinary of moments, and turn it into something that would touch the hearts of generations.

May he rest in peace.

Brendan Hayes, Bantry, Co Cork

Private policing?

This government’s appetite for privatising social goods and services seems endless. It is reasonable to wonder what government ministers and their huge departments are actually for anymore now that so many services have been outsourced

However, the latest proposal to contract private security to patrol public streets is surely a step too far and requires more consultation and debate. It appears a small unit within Dublin City Council, headed by an unelected individual, has decided to progress this proposal to the tender stage without even informing the elected members of the council. 

Following concerns raised, an extraordinary statement was issued by Dublin City Council stating that “these private security actors won’t have statutory powers to arrest, demand identification, require a person to leave a public street, search people, issue fines or enforce local authority by-laws”, which leaves one to wonder what exactly these “security actors” will be getting up to. 

And, of course, the other obvious question is who exactly would pay these “security actors”? If we, the taxpayers, are expected to foot the bill, then surely we too should be consulted in some way or another.

This proposal requires thorough scrutiny, especially given the derisory performance of the regulatory bodies that are supposed to ensure the public interest is served by such entities and must not be left in the hands of an unaccountable individual or body. Is it really too much to ask that one of our many ministers takes this matter in hand, explains what is going on, and shoulders the responsibility for it?

Jim O’Sullivan, Rathedmond, Co Sligo

Micheál Martin is letting us down

What genuinely frightens me about Taoiseach Micheál Martin is the spectacle of an Irish leader presiding over a country where ordinary people cannot afford a home, while corporations and other vested interests continue to benefit.

The British spent centuries treating Ireland as something to be exploited. Now we have an Irish taoiseach smiling his way through a system in which ordinary Irish people are once again paying the price.

He’s got the entire arrangement upside down. He is supposed to work for the people who elected him, not put corporations and vested interests ahead of them. Government is supposed to serve its citizens, not sacrifice them for the benefit of those already doing nicely.

This country is not his to sell; it belongs to the people who live here.

Alan T Kelly, Castlewarden, Co Kildare

More in this section

Revoiced

Newsletter

Had a busy week? Sign up for some of the best reads from the week gone by. Selected just for you.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited