We can’t produce food at Third World prices
Firstly, I don’t think we would agree on anything because judging by the tone of his letter, our views seem diametrically opposed.
The only subsidy which may be trade distorting is export refunds, and this is being phased out. I never once mentioned it in my letter headlined ‘WTO threat to our food supply (Irish Examiner letters, December 16).
I spoke of import tariffs which are a completely different thing.
Mr McGrath speaks of ‘basic economics’.
If he understands that subject he would know that European farmers cannot produce at Third World prices when we have First World costs, in the same way that no one could live here if they were paid Third World wages.
Wasn’t that what the Irish Ferries protest marches were about?
And that was why we in the Irish Cattle and Sheepfarmers’ Association supported them.
However, I would agree with one point made by Mr McGrath ... that rising food prices would encourage production. The only problem is one cannot turn on food production like a tap.
There will be a delay of a year or two, a long time if you’re hungry.
Finally, Mr McGrath wishes to choose where his food comes from. I hope he will always have that choice.
Edmond Phelan
Waterford Chairman
Irish Cattle and Sheepfarmers Association
9 Lyster House
Lyster Square
Portlaoise
Co Laois
