Host of questions remain over spying operation at GSOC
However, the statement from the ombudsman did confirm that there had been three security “threats” to its communication systems and that there had been “concerns” about the integrity of its security.
The chairman of the Garda Síochána Ombudsman Commission, Simon O’Brien, did not explain what the nature of the threats were, or state whether they actually constituted bugging or surveillance.
Crucially, he did say that, following an investigation, “no evidence of Garda misconduct” was found.
It a parallel statement issued by GSOC, the word threat was not used. Instead it referred to “three technical and electronic anomalies”.
It added: “These could not be conclusively explained and raised concerns among the investigation team in terms of the integrity of GSOC’s communications security. However, GSOC is satisfied that its databases were not compromised”.
While its databases were not compromised, we do not know whether phone conversations in the office’s conference room were listened into, as initially reported.
So, as of 6.30pm yesterday, we learned: A) GSOC’s communications security has been threatened; B) there’s no evidence the Gardaí were involved; and C) we don’t know who was behind it.
This was more than a day and a half after The Sunday Times carried the claims in a report — claims that both former GSOC commissioner Conor Brady and the Irish Council of Civil Liberties described as credible.
Throughout Sunday and into yesterday, senior officers in the force and leading figures in the Oireachtas said the clear inference was that the Gardaí were behind the spying operation.
Garda figures felt they were being maligned, albeit not directly and not on record. “It was just left hanging there as the inference without anyone actually saying it or clarifying that we weren’t suspected,” said one Garda source. GSOC’s refusal to comment throughout Sunday did not help matters.
In last night’s statement, the ombudsman said: “We did not wish to point fingers unnecessarily and we did not believe that widespread reporting would be conducive to public confidence.”
It said there was “no evidence” of Garda misconduct, but stopped short of saying they had no reason to believe, or suspect, their possible involvement.
The GSOC statement said: “The Commission decided to discontinue the investigation on the basis that no further action was necessary or reasonably practicable.”
Last night, Garda Commissioner Martin Callinan said he was “gravely concerned” that the GSOC statement contained “a clear indication that An Garda Síochána was in some way suspected in this matter”. He has sought clarification on what was the basis of this suspicion, the nature of the anomalies and did they constitute a security breach.
The whole affair has further poisoned an already difficult relationship between GSOC and the Garda Síochána. This is just as the watchdog is about to launch a major and highly sensitive investigation in allegations regarding the cancellation of penalty points.
It is unclear what is going on in the background behind this latest saga: Who leaked the information, and why, and the full story behind what happened. The public, on whose behalf GSOC, the Gardaí, and the Department of Justice operate, need further clarity on what is going on.
Justice Minister Alan Shatter is to brief the Cabinet this morning on his meeting with Mr O’Brien. Hopefully he will set out options for further investigation.
We have the extremely grave matter that the office was threatened, possibly bugged. There are serious questions here. What actually happened? What did it involve? What systems were targeted? Were phone conversations listened into? Involving what cases or issues?
That leads to who else could be behind it. There are a range of possibilities: From companies, to criminals, to foreign intelligence agencies, to sophisticated hackers — all with their own interests in GSOC investigations.
Security sources told the Irish Examiner that the technology to bug is commercially available, although it does require technical expertise to install and operate it.
The security source said it would be “suicide” and “lunacy” for the gardaí to have been involved, even if they covered their tracks. He pointed out that the bugging can be done remotely and that those involved would not need to physically access GSOC offices. However, they would need the actual phone number of the conference room and questioned how they would get that number.
A host of questions remain.






