Carney comments - Issue must be carefully considered

Mr Justice PAUL CARNEY’S remarks in relation to victim impact procedures focused on extremely sensitive matters.

He did not specifically name anybody, but there was no doubt he was referring to Majella Holohan’s statement at the trial of Wayne O’Donoghue, who was convicted of the manslaughter of her 11-year-old son Robert in Midleton in January 2005.

The judge has a reputation for diligence and hard work, and he has been passionate about his job. In this instance, he should be commended for having the courage and commitment to raise the matter.