We are non-aligned, but we are not neutral

JA BARNWELL (Irish Examiner letters, February 15) claims non-participation in an alliance proves Ireland is a neutral country.

Let me reiterate — the internationally legally accepted definition of neutrality means non-participation in a war between other countries. In no government publication, press release or Dáil answer on Ireland’s traditional policy of military neutrality have I ever seen a commitment to non-participation in a war, only non-participation in an alliance.

Non-participation in a military alliance does not guarantee non-participation in a war because you can still take part in a war even though you are not allied to anyone.

Non-alignment is different to neutrality because while neutrality is the absolute refusal to participate in a war, non-alignment leaves the option open.

Jack Lynch summed up Ireland’s traditional policy of military neutrality perfectly when he said: “We can make up our minds as to our neutrality in the light of circumstances prevailing”.

That is not a principled stance on neutrality but pathetic “whatever you’re having yourself” paddywackery.

Until Mr Barnwell or anyone else can provide evidence that Ireland’s traditional policy of military neutrality means non-participation in a war, I will stick with my stance that Ireland is not neutral, but non-aligned.

Jason FitzHarris

Rivervalley

Swords

Co Dublin