Government urged to improve children’s rights

THE Government has been asked to make three key changes over the next three months to improve children’s rights, including giving children an independent legal voice in their parents divorce proceedings.

The State is due to report to the UN Committee on the Rights of the Child in September to show how it is meeting the obligations to children it signed up to fourteen years ago.

Children’s Groups issued their shadow report to the Committee in Geneva yesterday, listing a litany of failures, shortcomings and missed opportunities.

The Children’s Rights Alliance, representing 80 groups and organisations that work with young people, highlighted breaches of children’s rights in Ireland, including the failure to amend the Constitution to give young people greater protection.

Following its presentation, the Alliance called on the Government to make three key positive changes for children ahead of its meeting with the UN in September.

Jillian van Turnhout, chief executive of the Alliance described the meeting with the world’s experts on children’s rights as very productive and informative.

“We have advised the UN as to the areas in which the State is failing to uphold children’s rights. Given that the State will now be focusing on preparations for its own hearing in September, we would ask them to also examine short-term changes that could be made between now and then.”

These short-term changes include:

* Amending the Criminal Justice Bill to make the age of criminal responsibility 12 for all offences.

* Bringing in existing legislation for a Guardian ad Litem in divorce and separation hearings.

* Drafting legislation to prohibit corporal punishment in families.

The Alliance highlighted the shortcomings of the Irish Constitution in relation to children and described it as the greatest overall barrier to implementing the Convention on the Rights of the Child.

The Constitution makes the status of children subordinate to the rights of the family and in addition the Supreme Court’s interpretation has tended to be adverse to the rights of children, the Alliance said.

As a result it is difficult for the State to intervene to protect children; legislative reform in adoption and involuntary admission to psychiatric hospitals is blocked and the Constitution is preventing the Convention being integrated into domestic law.

Earlier this year, work to amend the Constitution was proposed, but legal experts say it would not give children the protection that is required.

In September, the Government makes its report to the UN and will be questioned on it, especially in light of the report from the Children’s Alliance.

More in this section

Revoiced

Newsletter

Had a busy week? Sign up for some of the best reads from the week gone by. Selected just for you.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited