Illegal immigrants don’t have the right to become a state within a state

THE agitation in parts of the US for spurious rights for illegal immigrants is being defended by some Irish at home and by some Irish-Americans on bogus historical and legal grounds.

We were not merely migrants, but legal arrivals, who were permitted only because it suited the US, Canada, Australia, etc, to augment their labour supply. But we had absolutely no legal or moral right to enter or, if illegally present, no entitlement either to remain or to secure citizenship in any of these lands. The grant of citizenship and the control of sovereign territory are fundamental and vital attributes of any independent state. Virtual non-enforcement of, say, US border controls, or of any other rights, cannot of itself invalidate the rights so laxly defended.

Despite its huge land frontier with Canada and Mexico, the US still has a tiny border patrol, plus a border landscape that facilitates easy transit of people or goods, or bombs or drugs.

And should the US freely choose to permit any illegals who now abandon their underground mode to apply to be considered for work permits, or even citizenship, then it would do well to retain in full the firm basis of American integration from the very beginning — “we are all Americans”.

No hyphenated Americans. One flag, one language, one country, one law.

The alternative is the European nightmare of Brixton and Toxteth, or a rioting Paris banlieu. We have all been warned.

Tom Carew

Merton Drive

Dublin 6