'He is missing from every memory we make': Bereaved parents fight for changes in home birth service

Ben Kane died just five days after being born as parents settle High Court action against HSE and National Maternity Hospital
Ben's parents Niamh Gray and James Kane at the Four Courts after the hearing of their case on Thursday. Picture: Collins Courts

Ben's parents Niamh Gray and James Kane at the Four Courts after the hearing of their case on Thursday. Picture: Collins Courts

“Ben’s life was short, but it was powerful and we hope that he has left a legacy which will help protect all the babies who come after him.” 

These were the words of the parents of Ben Kane, who died when he was only five days old as they settled a High Court action against the HSE and the National Maternity Hospital over their son’s death.

Baby Ben was delivered at the Dublin hospital after an attempted home birth, but he died five days later on February 12, 2022.

His parents have fought for key changes in home birth services which includes better communication between midwives and hospitals.

In the High Court on Thursday, Mr Justice Paul Coffey commended the couple for their work to ensure key recommendations are implemented after a systems analysis review following Ben’s death.

Niamh Gray and James Kane, of Lusk, Co Dublin, had sued the National Maternity Hospital, Holles Street, Dublin, and the HSE.

The family’s counsel, Bruce Antoniotti, instructed by solicitor Rachael Liston, told the court there had been no concern in relation to the appropriateness of a home birth. 

Ms Gray’s waters broke at 8am on February 6 but when it emerged in the early hours the baby could not be delivered at home and she was transferred to hospital. 

Counsel said it was their case that proper tests should have been ascertained sooner and if the mother had been transferred to hospital earlier, they contended Baby Ben would now be alive and well.

HSE accepts recommendations

In a letter to Ben’s parents, which was read to the court, the HSE said it accepted the recommendations made in the wake of the system analysis review. 

It also apologised “for any aspect of care that could have contributed to a different outcome for Baby Ben".

The National Maternity Hospital, in a letter that was read to court, expressed “sincere and deepest sympathies “on Baby Ben’s death. It also accepted the findings of the system analysis review and apologised “for any aspect of care that could have contributed to a different outcome.

“We are also truly sorry that our bereavement care after Ben’s death did not meet your needs and for the added distress this has caused,"

In the proceedings, it was claimed the delivery and immediate aftermath of the birth were profoundly shocking for both parents.

Ms Gray, it is claimed, was in severe distress and pain during the latter stage of her labour and when Ben was born, he was limp and required resuscitation. He was diagnosed as suffering from hypoxia ischaemic encephalopathy.

He was put on palliative care on February 11 and died the next day. 

Ben missed every day, say parents

Outside the Four Courts, Ms Gray, with Mr Kane by her side, said Ben is missed every day.

“He is missing from every memory we make. Our grief does not fade we are just learning to carry it. This is a pain no parent should ever know,” she said.

“Knowing that policy change has already taken place due to Ben’s death was very important to us.

"We hope that these changes will ensure that no other family experiences what we have and no other precious baby loses their life." 

Mr Kane said it was very important for Ben’s legacy that they fought for change.

“Nothing was ever going to bring Ben back but if his little life can save maybe a few parents and families going through such a travesty, that is the little mark he has made on this world," he said.

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited