Elon Musk fails in High Court challenge to halt media watchdog investigation

Mr Justice O'Donnell said his judgment rejecting Mr Musk's challenge was intended to operate as a 'form of lead judgment, which will allow shorter judgments to be delivered in the other cases'
Elon Musk, who has an address in Texas, was the first applicant in the case against Coimisiún na Meán (CnM). File photo: AP/Evan Vucci

Elon Musk, who has an address in Texas, was the first applicant in the case against Coimisiún na Meán (CnM). File photo: AP/Evan Vucci

The High Court has rejected a "lead" case brought by Elon Musk and his X Holding Corporation to quash a decision by media watchdog Coimisiún na Meán (CnM) to launch an investigation into suspected contraventions of provisions under Digital Services Regulations by 'X'.

In his judgment on Wednesday, Mr Justice Barry O'Donnell said Mr Musk and X Holdings Corp had, in judicial review proceedings, sought a quashing of CnM beginning an investigation under the Broadcasting Act 2009 over suspected contraventions of the Digital Services Regulation (DSR) by X, formerly Twitter, because the watchdog could not identify who was to be correctly investigated regarding the social media platform.

Mr Justice O'Donnell said his judgment rejecting Mr Musk's challenge was intended to operate as a "form of lead judgment, which will allow shorter judgments to be delivered in the other cases".

Mr Musk, who has an address in Texas, was the first applicant in the case, with the second applicant being X Holdings Corp while notice party X Internet Unlimited Company (XIUC) — a company registered in Ireland — was added to proceedings.

Since the proceedings commenced in December 2025, the court heard there has been a "complicated process" involving changes to the corporate structures of the various companies.

It had been argued by Mr Musk's lawyers that the CnM acted unlawfully in commencing the investigation without a prior determination as to whether the first and second applicants were the relevant service providers of X in an Irish context.

In December 2025, Ms Justice Mary Rose Gearty granted Mr Musk and X Holdings a stay on the CnM investigation, which, following a hearing, was then continued in January of this year with reporting restrictions concerning sensitive confidential information.

In rejecting the opposition to the investigation, Mr Justice O'Donnell said: "I have concluded that the application for relief, by way of judicial review, should be refused and that the investigation should be permitted to proceed."

"It is not necessary to go any further than to find that it is not unlawful for CnM to structure an investigation in the way proposed. The court’s findings mean that should the investigation proceed it would [therefore] be inappropriate to engage in any further analysis of the issues that may be the subject of the investigation, as those are matters that remain undetermined.

"The court has concluded that the application for relief by way of judicial review should be refused. It follows that the stay on the investigation should be lifted, and the court will make orders to those effects," said the judge.

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited