Midleton not suitable for 'natural' flood defence measures, report finds
Report concluded natural measures would not contribute to any reduction in flood because of the nature of tidal flooding in the area. Picture: Eddie O'Hare
A report by an adviser to the British Environment Agency on the potential for "natural flood management" measures (NFM) to protect Midleton concluded it would not be feasible for the East Cork town.
It emerged at a Cork County Council meeting that this assessment was the first of its kind to be carried out in Ireland, but the British group found engineered flood defences would be required along the River Owenacurra, with scope for only minimal natural defences.
It was concluded natural measures would not contribute to any reduction in flood because of the nature of tidal flooding in the area.
In the context of the scale of intervention, related costs, landowner engagement required, and the logistics of construction and maintenance of natural measures, the report found it was not a technically viable solution for Midleton, either as a standalone option or even in combination with other measures.
A summary of these findings was read out to councillors by their chief executive Valerie O’Sullivan after Social Democrats councillor Liam Quaide urged the council to follow the lead on natural flood management (NFM) projects taken by some local authorities in Britain.
Mr Quaide said some local authorities in Britain had successfully used NFM projects, highlighting that between 1999 and 2007, the town of Pickering, North Yorkshire, was flooded four times, with the damage running to many millions of pounds.
“The town was refused a £20m flood defence scheme as the cost was deemed too high to protect a limited number of residents. Locals engaged with the Environmental Agency and Forestry Commission to study the root cause of the repeated flooding which was water rushing off the nearby hills and dales.
"A project was developed that changed land management practices around the town that slowed the flow of water downstream. The town of Pickering has remained dry in recent years while other towns in that region have been repeatedly flooded by increasingly severe rainfall,” Mr Quaide said.
He said scientific research carried out by Bangor University into a land management project in Pontbren, Wales, which was pioneered by 10 farmers, found soil under mixed native trees absorbs water 67 times faster than under grass.
Native trees have such deep roots they provide channels to send the water much further underground. The soil under native trees absorbs water and then releases it slowly.
“Between 1997 and 2016 the farmers planted 120,000 trees, 5% of 1,000 hectares. They reinstated 26.5km of hedgerows and created 12 ponds covering 5.4 acres of ground. These ponds are essentially restored natural wetland sites which act as reservoirs.
"The research found if all farmers in the catchment followed their example, flooding downstream would reduce by 29%. Full reforestation would reduce the flooding by 50% or more,” Mr Quaide said.
Fianna Fáil councillor Gillian Coughlan said natural measures might be used in conjunction with major flood relief works as they may reduce the need for concrete protection structures which are not always very pleasing to the eye.
Ms O’Sullivan said the council was quite willing to look at the possibility of using NFM on other flood projects, but only if they think they are feasible.




