Air France and Airbus on trial 13 years after Atlantic jet disaster in which three Irish women died

Air France and Airbus on trial 13 years after Atlantic jet disaster in which three Irish women died

Flight 447 vanished in pitch darkness during an equatorial storm en route from Rio de Janeiro to Paris on June 1, 2009. File picture: AP /Christophe Ena

More than 13 years after an Air France jet plunged into the Atlantic, killing all 228 people on board, the French carrier and planemaker Airbus go on trial in a Paris court next week with relatives seeking "light at the end of a long tunnel".

Flight 447 vanished in pitch darkness during an equatorial storm en route from Rio de Janeiro to Paris on June 1, 2009.

Three Irish women — Dr Aisling Butler, 26, of Roscrea, Co Tipperary, Dr Jane Deasy, 27, from Dublin and Dr Eithne Walls, 28, from Co Down  — were among those who lost their lives in the crash.

The three friends had studied medicine together in Trinity College Dublin and were returning from a holiday in Brazil when the plane disaster took place.

Maksim Ivanova, 25, a young Estonian man who was living in Dublin, also died in the tragedy. His Dublin-based mother was later awarded €68,000 in High Court damages in 2013 in respect of her son’s death.

After a two-year search for the A330's black boxes, French investigators found pilots had mishandled the temporary loss of data from iced-up sensors and pushed the 205-tonne jet into an aerodynamic stall or freefall, without responding to alerts.

But the BEA accident agency also disclosed that Air France had expressed concerns about increased icing incidents before the crash and had started receiving improved speed probes. Experts say the relative roles of pilot or sensor error, as well as erratic displays or fatigue, will be key to the historic trial.

Monday's opening hearing will mark the first time French companies have been directly placed on trial for "involuntary manslaughter" following an air crash, rather than individuals.

While corporate reputations and a long-awaited catharsis for families are at stake, the nine-week trial is not expected to lead to significant financial penalties. However, experts say larger sums have been paid in compensation or civil settlements.

Maximum fine

The maximum fine for either company, if convicted of involuntary manslaughter, is just €225,000, or five times the maximum monetary penalty for an individual, who unlike a company can also face jail, according to French legal experts.

That represents a little over two minutes of pre-Covid planemaking revenues for Airbus or five minutes of passenger revenues for airline parent Air France-KLM, according to 2019 data. There are also significant legal costs.

Even so, AF447 sparked a broad rethink about training and technology and is seen as one of a handful of accidents that changed aviation. But reforms have followed the methodical pace of global regulation or become mired in industry disagreements.

Among dozens of safety recommendations, experts say the investigation led to critical changes in the way pilots are trained to cope with mid-air upsets, or loss of control.

But a call from the BEA for studies into better tracking in radar dead-zones met little response until the disappearance of a second jet, Malaysia Airlines MH370, five years later.

Over a decade after the BEA's initial findings, there are no signs of another of its longstanding concerns being addressed.

Cockpit cameras

Although black boxes provide important clues, the trial could rekindle a long-running privacy row over whether cockpits should also be monitored visually to decipher future accidents, especially now security cameras are part of everyday life.

In 2011, the BEA recommended the addition of cockpit video recordings to be consulted only in case of an accident, supplementing existing voice and data information.

It has been pushing for their introduction since an earlier Airbus crash 30 years ago, and the US National Transportation Safety Board last year put the same idea on its list of "Most Wanted" safety improvements — saying it would have been "extremely helpful" in investigating Boeing 737 MAX crashes.

Pilot unions oppose cameras as an invasion of privacy, while some airline industry groups have questioned the cost. The US Federal Aviation Administration said it encouraged cameras on a voluntary basis while studying screen-capture technology.

The trial at Paris Criminal Court runs until December 8.

• Reuters 

More in this section

Puzzles logo

Puzzles hub

Visit our brain gym where you will find simple and cryptic crosswords, sudoku puzzles and much more. Updated at midnight every day. PS ... We would love to hear your feedback on the section right HERE.

Text header

From florist to fraudster, leaving a trail of destruction from North Cork, to Waterford, to Clare, to Wexford and through the midlands ... learn how mistress of re-invention, Catherine O'Brien, scammed her way around rural Ireland.

Let Me Tell You

Let Me Tell You is a new bespoke podcast series from 

Logo IE

Hosts Daniel McConnell and Paul Hosford take a look back at some of the most dramatic moments in recent Irish political history from the unique perspective of one of the key players involved.

Bespoke political podcast series from

Logo IE
Execution Time: 0.238 s