Air France, Airbus to stand trial over 2009 crash in which three Irish died

Three Irish women, Dr Aisling Butler, Dr Jane Deasy and Dr Eithne Walls, lost their lives in the crash
Air France, Airbus to stand trial over 2009 crash in which three Irish died

Aisling Butler (26) of Roscrea, Co Tipperary, Jane Deasy (27) from Dublin and Eithne Walls (28), from Co Down, were among those who lost their lives in the crash

Air France and Airbus should stand trial on involuntary manslaughter charges over a 2009 crash in the Atlantic Ocean which killed 228 people, a French court has ruled.

Air France flight AF447 from Rio de Janeiro to Paris crashed on June 1 2009 killing everyone on board.

Three Irish women, Dr Aisling Butler (26) of Roscrea, Co Tipperary, Dr Jane Deasy (27) from Dublin and Dr Eithne Walls (28), from Co Down, were among those who lost their lives in the crash. 

The three friends had studied medicine together in Trinity College Dublin and were returning from a holiday in Brazil when the plane disaster took place.

Maksim Ivanova (25), a young Estonian man who was living in Dublin, also died in the tragedy. His Dublin-based mother was later awarded €68,000 in High Court damages in respect of her son’s death in 2013. 

Dr Jane Deasy's body was recovered from the tragedy, but Dr Butler and Dr Walls bodies have never been recovered  
Dr Jane Deasy's body was recovered from the tragedy, but Dr Butler and Dr Walls bodies have never been recovered  

On Wednesday, a French court, ruling on a request from French prosecutors, overturned a previous ruling that there should not be a trial.

French investigators found the crew mishandled loss of speed readings from sensors blocked with ice from a storm, and caused the aircraft to stall by holding its nose too high.

It took two years to find the wreckage of the Airbus A330 jet, which was eventually located by remote-controlled submarines at a depth of 13,000 feet.

Airbus and Air France both said on Wednesday they planned to file appeals against the ruling before a higher court.

AirFrance has indicated it will appeal the ruling.
AirFrance has indicated it will appeal the ruling.

In a statement, Airbus said the court decision "does not reflect in any way the conclusions of the investigation."

A spokesperson for Air France said the airline "maintains that it committed no criminal fault at the root of this tragic accident."

A report in 2014 found that two senior pilots were asleep just moments before the airliner crashed.

Previously unheard recordings from a black box recording which was recovered from the wreck of the aeroplane indicate one of the pilot's final words were: "F***, we're dead."

'Too short' lives lost 

Speaking after the crash, Dr Eithne Walls’ family described her as an "extraordinary person who brought light to the lives of everyone she touched."

“She was beautiful in every way, especially of spirit. She had a passion for life that permeated, enlivened and enriched those around her.

“We feel privileged to have shared her too short life, and the countless memories of her will stay with us forever," they said. 

Family and friends attending a memorial Mass for County Down doctor Eithne Walls who was killed in the Air France plane crash.
Family and friends attending a memorial Mass for County Down doctor Eithne Walls who was killed in the Air France plane crash.

Dr Wall graduated from Trinity College Dublin alongside friends Dr Butler and Dr Deasy in 2007.

Her body, alongside Dr Butler's, has never been found.

Speaking ten years after the tragedy, Dr Butler's father said "it's one of those things that we're living with every day.”

“The future was what she was thinking of all the time, she had a fantastic love of people, she just wanted to bring her medicine to her patients and to let them have the benefit of it.”

Dr Aisling Butler's body has never been found
Dr Aisling Butler's body has never been found

Dr Deasy's body was recovered a month after the crash to the relief of her family and friends.

The young doctor was remembered at her funeral as an "exceptionally special, loving and unique person."

- Aditional reporting by Reuters 

More in this section

IE_logo_newsletters

Select your favourite newsletters and get the best of Irish Examiner delivered to your inbox