Judge attacks system of short release

ONE of the country’s most outspoken district court judges has accused prison authorities of having no regard for the victims of crime when they let prisoners out on temporary release after just a few weeks behind bars.

Judge Michael Pattwell said victims of crime were “having their rights vindicated by the courts and three weeks later they see those responsible walking down the street”.

“It is very unfair to the law-abiding citizen. Have the prison authorities no regard for the victims?”

He made his comments during the sentencing of two Cork brothers who appeared in Midleton District Court charged with a number of offences, including burglary, which were committed while they were out on temporary release from prison. The brothers, James and Jason Butler, have more than 120 previous convictions between them.

“How much longer is this going to go on? I would ask the taxpayer, when are you going to rise up in revolt and say we are not going to stand for this anymore,” Judge Pattwell said.

“I might as well be shouting in the middle of the Sahara desert because no one is listening. People are breaking into properties while they are being paid on the dole, when are you going to shout stop?”

Imposing a 20-month prison sentence on the two brothers, Judge Pattwell said he would put money on the fact that the two brothers would be walking the streets in the coming weeks.

During a recent Dáil debate on prison overcrowding it was suggested that according to prison service figures up to 700 prisoners could be on temporary release from prison on any given day.

On one particular day earlier this month, there were 320 prisoners in Cork in a facility which had bed capacity for 272. A further 153 were on temporary release.

Responding to Judge Pattwell’s comments last night, Irish Prison Officers Association president Jim Mitchell said temporary release was undoubtedly being used to ease the enormous pressure on an overcrowded prison service.

“Previous ministers gave us extra courts, extra judges and gardaí. From the public’s perception that’s great. Unfortunately, however, there was no increase in prison spaces so we are not able to meet the influx of prisoners,” he said.

“We have people who are coming in for five or 10 days for non-payment of fines and might be let out that afternoon on temporary release.”

Mr Mitchell said community service was a viable option as an alternative to prison, especially for young repeat offenders.

“I think of the image of Boy George in an orange jumpsuit picking up rubbish. At least with community service there is someone there to make sure you do the work you are supposed to and there is humiliation in it as well,” he said.

“Unfortunately for some going to prison doesn’t cost them a second thought and it’s more like home for them than anything,” he said.

Mr Mitchell also pointed to a consistent increase in the total prisoner population over recent years, with surges in the number of sentenced prisoners.

More in this section

Lunchtime News

Newsletter

Get a lunch briefing straight to your inbox at noon daily. Also be the first to know with our occasional Breaking News emails.

Cookie Policy Privacy Policy Brand Safety FAQ Help Contact Us Terms and Conditions

© Examiner Echo Group Limited