Farmers fined €100,000 following fatal fall
71-year-old Michael Byrne was helping his neighbours secure profile metal sheeting to the roof of an agricultural building when he fell through a gap, landing on the concrete floor below.
Father and son partners in a farm business have been fined €100,000 after a man was killed in an accident during the construction of a new shed in Co Laois three years ago.
71-year-old Michael Byrne fell to his death while working on the construction of a new shed on Seamus McEvoy and Patrick McEvoy’s farm in Coolderry, Ballacolla, Co Laois, on October 9, 2023.
He was helping his neighbours secure profile metal sheeting to the roof of an agricultural building when he fell through a gap, landing on the concrete floor below.
At Portlaoise Circuit Court on Thursday, November 12, Judge Jonathan Dunphy fined each man €50,000.
Mr Byrne’s son read a victim impact statement on behalf of the family, in which they said they had written to the DPP asking it not to prosecute the McEvoys.
"While we have lost a husband, father, brother and grandfather, we also recognise that the McEvoy family have had to live with the consequences of this terrible accident. We appreciate that this has undoubtedly been an extremely difficult and distressing experience for them also," he said.
"As a family, we do not hold the McEvoy family personally accountable for Michael’s death... We have no wish to see another family experience further hardship or distress as a consequence of what has happened."
Seamus McEvoy and Patrick McEvoy pleaded guilty to offences relating to workplace safety, failing to appoint a project supervisor during construction and the planning of work at height.
Patrick McEvoy also admitted failing to ensure the roof had no gap through which a worker could fall. The offences can carry penalties of up to two years’ imprisonment and/or a fine of up to €3m.
Commenting, Eibhlin O’Leary, assistant chief executive of the Health and Safety Authority, said: "Where work at height is being undertaken, known risks must be identified and appropriate precautions put in place before work begins. This case is a tragic reminder of the devastating consequences that can arise when adequate protections are not in place.”





