Alan Healy: Ireland is facing a cyber winter with little sign of a thaw
A number of credit unions in Ireland were impacted by a cybersecurity attack in recent weeks.
It has been a tough few weeks for those who value their personal data and wish to live and work uninterrupted.
Both locally and internationally, the public has been hit by a series of major cyberattacks and outages, many with real-world cost implications.
The incidents span a range of sectors from banking, hospitality, cryptocurrency and even our fridges. The world is paying a dearer and dearer price for the more connected space we live in.
In October, Revolut was impacted by a Google Cloud-related outage that left some customers struggling to make payments. This week, cybersecurity incidents hit our credit unions. Killarney's Gleneagle Hotel told some of its guests that some data had been stolen.
In a wider context, heart stent and pacemaker producer Boston Scientific has twice cut its sales outlook following its hacking incident earlier this year. At the same time, we are faced with a never-ending barrage of scam ads using the faces of Claire Byrne, Patrick Kielty and AIB's Colin Hunt to dupe savers.
It is not happening in isolation. Internationally, hackers stole around $6.3bn in cryptocurrency in just 20 minutes from the Binance exchange last month, the biggest digital heist in history, so far.
We can call it a cyber winter with little chance of a thaw.
As a society and a civilisation, we have gone all-in on digital. Banking, shopping, entertainment, healthcare and work are all done online in some part. Even our fridges and doorbells are connected. The use of cash is fading rapidly, and there is little appetite to go back, whether from consumers, businesses or Governments.
However, there is a growing cost for the digital world we live in, and it is becoming more expensive when things break.
IBM's latest Cost of a Data Breach report puts the global average cost of a cybersecurity breach at $4.99m, up 12% from last year. Cybersecurity Ventures estimates that cybercrime costs the world economy $10.5 trillion each year and is expected to reach $15.6 trillion by 2029.
Those numbers can become abstract, but the Irish numbers are not. The Central Bank said payment fraud here jumped 27% to €179m last year, and almost 70% of the money stolen ended up in accounts outside the State.
Larger companies can deal with the thefts much more easily than smaller ones. Binance, the crypto exchange hacked last month, was able to guarantee all its customers' deposits.
A report from Hiscox surveyed 300 Irish firms with fewer than 250 staff and found that those hit by an attack lost an average of 34 hours to disruption, almost a full working week. More than a third (36%) lost business opportunities or partnerships afterwards, and 34% put growth or expansion plans on hold. The cost for smaller businesses of a hack or a breach is much harsher.
For a manufacturer in Mallow or a hotel in Killarney, that means orders missed, staff left idle and customers who may not come back.
And these cyber threats come against the next wave of expansion, with businesses small and large driving headlong into AI adoption.
And AI is making attacks cheaper to run and firms easier to get into. IBM found that more than one in four organisations hit by a malicious attack reported AI involvement, up 56% in a year, with deepfake impersonation the most common form.
Closer to home, one survey found 80% of agribusinesses use AI, but half have no procedures governing it. More than 80% of chartered accountants are using AI each week, with the technology now permanently embedded in the profession.
It might be tempting to suggest a return to the good old days of paper ledgers, printed invoices, cash transactions, and cheque payments. But the analogue past was not free of fraud either. Fraud follows money wherever it goes.
Assuming we remain committed to the digital present and future, Ireland will find itself at the centre of future regulation.
We host the European headquarters of many of the major tech companies.
The Data Protection Commission is effectively Europe's tech referee, meting out fines and obligations on the firms. It slapped Google with a €403m fine this year, and dating app Tinder was stung for €11m this month.
But data protection is only half the job. Fining firms for how they handle our data does little to stop criminals stealing it. New European cybersecurity rules, which bring mid-sized firms under mandatory security obligations, are the bigger test of whether Ireland can lead on security as well as privacy.
The onslaught of attacks is not going to end, and it is questionable how many companies treat cybersecurity as an IT add-on rather than baking it into policies and procedures. Even then, there is a need for affordable support, training and incident response, particularly for SMEs.



