'Too easy to lie back and do nothing': Father of Irish doctor killed in Air France crash to appeal court decision

'Too easy to lie back and do nothing': Father of Irish doctor killed in Air France crash to appeal court decision
Dr Aisling Butler of Roscrea, Co Tipperary, one of the passengers on board the Air France airliner that vanished over the Atlantic Ocean. Picture: PA Wire

The father of an Irish doctor who perished when an Air France transatlantic flight from Brazil crashed has said that the family will appeal a decision by French judges to drop charges against the airline and Airbus.

John Butler, father of Aisling Butler, one of three Irish women who were killed in the crash, told RTÉ radio’s News at One that he will be joining with other families in appealing the judgement.

On Thursday, French judges dropped charges against Air France and Airbus over the crash in 2009 that killed all 228 people onboard, blaming the pilots for losing control of the plane.

In their conclusions, seen by Reuters, the judges said the pilots of the Airbus A330 had failed to process all the warnings and instrument readings provided by the aircraft.

The plane crashed en route from Rio de Janeiro to Paris after entering an aerodynamic stall and falling from an altitude of 38,000 feet during a storm, its engines running but its wings losing lift.

Aisling Butler, of Roscrea, Co Tipperary, Jane Deasy from Dublin and Eithne Walls, originally from Belfast, were among the dead.

"The direct cause of the accident is the crew's loss of control of the aircraft's trajectory," the judges determined.

A lawyer representing the families of victims said an appeal against the judges' decision would be lodged immediately.

Mr Butler said that as a family they were very disappointed, but not really surprised at the decision.

“We are very, very disappointed, it is 10 years hence, we never got the body of Aisling back and it's one of those things that we're living with every day.”

He added that he doesn't understand the logic of the magistrates’ decision.

“Everyone is responsible for what they do. Air France is the national airline of France and everyone was a paying passenger.

"Airbus are the manufacturer and supplier of the aircraft involved, so they are responsible.

“Yes, we will join an appeal by relatives, ‘tis too easy to lie back and do nothing.

"This organisation was put together to really remind Air France, remind Airbus and certainly remind Air France as to the way they train their pilots so that this never happens again.”

Of his daughter, he said: “The future was what she was thinking of all the time, she had a fantastic love of people, she just wanted to bring her medicine to her patients and to let them have the benefit of it.”


More in this Section

Book of evidence prepared against member of gardaíBook of evidence prepared against member of gardaí

Woman's hotel stay in Cork ends in arrest after teacups and glasses thrown at the wallWoman's hotel stay in Cork ends in arrest after teacups and glasses thrown at the wall

Teen wrapped chain around knuckles for assaultTeen wrapped chain around knuckles for assault

Virgin Media staff vote 'overwhelmingly' for industrial action over job cutsVirgin Media staff vote 'overwhelmingly' for industrial action over job cuts


Lifestyle

For our food special, our Currabinny duo, James Kavanagh and William Murray, dish up their top festive side plates.The Currabinny Cooks: Festive side plates to dish up this Christmas

More From The Irish Examiner