Dunnes Stores loses appeal relating to tax assessments on plastic bag levy

Dunnes Stores loses appeal relating to tax assessments on plastic bag levy

Dunnes Stores has lost its Supreme Court appeal concerning the validity of laws under which the Revenue Commissioners later raised tax assessments of €36.5m on the supermarket chain concerning certain plastic bags.

The five-judge court, while critical of the "overly complex" legislation, rejected the company's claim the "flimsy" plastic bags at issue did not fall within the scope of the plastic bag levy.

The tax assessments were raised over a four year period to November 2008 after the Revenue alleged the levies due for certain plastic bags had not been collected.

Dunnes did not accept the assessments and argued the plastic bags in relation to which those assessments were made were not subject to the levy.

In its action against the Revenue Commissioners and the State, Dunnes claimed the levy only relates to larger bags given to customers at "point of sale" for their shopping and the assessments wrongly included other bags used for wrapping for fruit and vegetables or for hygiene purposes.

The definition of plastic bag in the relevant 2001 regulations was "so uncertain" as to render the regulations invalid, it argued among a range of claims.

After it lost in the High Court, it appealed to the Supreme Court where a five-judge court today unanimously dismissed its appeal.

Giving the court's main judgment, Mr Justice William McKechnie said the relevant sections of the Waste Management Act 1996, as amended in 2001, and of the regulations made under that Act, are difficult to construe.

Given the direct liability obligation imposed as a result of the measures, one would have thought they should be drafted with "due precision" and in a manner which gives "direct and clear" effect to the underlying purpose of the legislative scheme.

"That can scarcely be said in this case," he said.

In a concurring judgment making brief observations on the relevant laws, Mr Justice John MacMenamin said they are "overly complex" and "surely capable of a much clearer definition".

He said the provisions have an "entirely laudable" social purpose, to reduce use of plastic packaging which poses a hazard to the environment.

However, the definitions of bag, such as those used at "point of sale", are "not only awkward but unnecessary".

"Neither public policy nor benign purposes should stand in the way of clarity," he added.

In the main judgment, Mr Justice McKechnie, having applied the rules of statutory interpretation, found the Waste Management (Environmental Levy Plastic Bag) Regulations 2001 covered the type of bag at issue.

He rejected as "without substance" Dunnes claim the regulations were made by the Minister for the Environment in excess of the provisions of the parent Act, the Waste Management Act 1996.

He also dismissed Dunnes' claims the Revenue acted in breach of fair procedures and/or natural and constitutional justice in not providing adequate details of the basis for calculating the tax assessments.

Dunnes had claimed the alleged failure of the Revenue in that regard meant its appeal to the Appeals Commissioners against the assessments, which remains adjourned as a result of the legal proceedings, has been compromised.

The Appeals Commissioners is the most appropriate forum to address the fairness issue if it should remain alive, the judge said.

He dismissed a further claim that section 72 of the 1996 Act, conferring power on the Minister to make regulations concerning the plastic bag levy, is unconstitutional.

He disagreed with Dunnes claims that section 72 constitutes an impermissible delegation of legislative power to the Minister and fails to set out the necessary principles and policies.

More on this topic

Gascoigne describes sex assault allegations as ‘year of hell’Gascoigne describes sex assault allegations as ‘year of hell’

Teen kicked mum outside courtTeen kicked mum outside court

€108k for psychiatric nurse's injuries in fall and car crash€108k for psychiatric nurse's injuries in fall and car crash

‘Medication made mother an addict’- family of woman who died by suicide‘Medication made mother an addict’- family of woman who died by suicide

More in this Section

Serious Fraud Office closes Libor rigging investigationSerious Fraud Office closes Libor rigging investigation

Johnson insists EU free trade agreement can be struck amid no-deal Brexit fearsJohnson insists EU free trade agreement can be struck amid no-deal Brexit fears

IDA Ireland: Era of optimism with growth evident in all sectorsIDA Ireland: Era of optimism with growth evident in all sectors

Renault warning of slowing sales haunts rest of European car industryRenault warning of slowing sales haunts rest of European car industry


Lifestyle

Ovarian cancer has been dubbed ‘the silent killer’. Christina Henry tells Rowena Walsh why she is one of the lucky onesAgeing with attitude: Life after ovarian cancer

Jamie Oliver is on a mission to get everyone eating more vegetables with the release of his new book, Veg.A selection of recipes from Jamie Oliver's new book Veg

More From The Irish Examiner