The parents of Tamerlan Tsarnaev have insisted that he went to Dagestan and Chechnya last year to visit relatives and had nothing to do with militants operating in the volatile part of Russia.
His father said he slept a lot of the time but the Boston Marathon bombing suspect could not have been immune to the attacks which savaged the region during his six-month stay.
Investigators are now focusing on the trip that Tsarnaev made to Russia in January 2012 which has raised many questions.
His father said his son stayed with him in Makhachkala, the capital of Dagestan, where the family lived briefly before moving to the US a decade ago. The father only recently returned.
“He was here, with me in Makhachkala,” Anzor Tsarnaev told the Associated Press in a telephone interview. “He slept until 3pm and, you know, I would ask him ’Have you come here to sleep?’ He used to go visiting, here and there. He would go to eat somewhere. Then he would come back and go to bed.”
Tamerlan, 26, and his 19-year-old brother, Dzhokhar – both ethnic Chechens - are accused of setting off the two bombs near the finish line of the Boston Marathon on April 15 which killed three people and wounded more than 180 others. Three days later, Tamerlan died in a shootout with police, while his brother was later captured alive but wounded.
No evidence has emerged since to link Tamerlan to militant groups in Russia’s Caucasus.
Yesterday, the Caucasus Emirate, which Russia and the US consider a terrorist organisation, denied involvement in the Boston attack.
A woman who works in a small shop opposite Mr Tsarnaev’s apartment building said she only saw his son during the course of one month last summer. She described him as a dandy.
“He dressed in a very refined way,” Madina Abdullaeva said. “His boots were the same colour as his clothes. They were summer boots, light, with little holes punched in the leather.”
Mr Tsarnaev said they also travelled to neighbouring Chechnya.
“He went with me twice, to see my uncles and aunts. I have lots of them,” the father said.
He said they also visited one of his daughters, who lives in the Chechen town of Urus-Martan with her husband. His son-in-law’s brothers all work in the police force under Chechen leader Ramzan Kadyrov, he said.
Moscow has given Mr Kadyrov a free hand to stabilise Chechnya following two wars between federal troops and Chechen separatists beginning in 1994, and his feared police and security forces have been accused of rampant rights abuses.
What began in Chechnya as a fight for independence has morphed into an Islamic insurgency that has spread throughout Russia’s Caucasus, with the worst of the violence now in Dagestan.
In February 2012, shortly after Tamerlan’s arrival in Dagestan, a four-day operation to wipe out several militant bands in Chechnya and Dagestan left 17 police and at least 20 militants dead. In May, two car bombs shook Makhachkala, killing at least 13 people and wounding about 130 more.
Other bombings and shootings targeting police and other officials took place nearly daily.
The Caucasus Emirate said yesterday that its mujahedin are not fighting with the US.
“We are at war with Russia, which is not only responsible for the occupation of the Caucasus, but also for heinous crimes against Muslims,” it said in a statement on the Kavkaz Centre website.
The group suggested that Russia’s secret services would have had a greater interest in carrying out the attack in Boston.
Despite the violence in Dagestan, Mr Tsarnaev said yesterday that his son did not want to leave and had thoughts on how he could go into business. But the father said he encouraged him to go back to the US and try to get citizenship. Tamerlan returned to the US in July.
His mother said he was questioned upon arrival at New York’s airport.
“And he told me on the phone ’Imagine, mama, they were asking me such interesting questions as if I were some strange and scary man: Where did you go? What did you do there?”’ Zubeidat Tsarnaeva recalled her son telling her at the time.
When the two ethnic Chechen suspects were identified, the FBI said it reviewed its records and found that, in early 2011, a foreign government – which law enforcement officials confirmed was Russia – had asked for information about Tamerlan Tsarnaev. The FBI said it was told that he was a “follower of radical Islam” and was preparing to travel to this foreign country to join unspecified underground groups.
The FBI said it responded by interviewing Tamerlan and family members, but found no terrorism activity.
Both parents insist that the FBI continued to monitor Tamerlan and that both of their sons were set up.
Their mother yesterday went so far as to claim that the FBI had contacted her elder son after the deadly bombs exploded at the marathon. If true it would be the first indication that the FBI considered him a suspect before Boston descended into violence on Thursday.
At FBI headquarters in Washington, spokesman Michael Kortan stood by the bureau’s public statement of Friday in which it described a 2011 FBI interview of Tamerlan Tsarnaev.
Mr Kortan said the 2011 interview was the only FBI contact with him. The FBI statement said the bureau did not learn of the identity of Tamerlan and his brother until Friday after the gun battle in which Tamerlan was killed.
The mother’s claim could not be independently confirmed, and she has made statements in the past that appeared to show a lack of full understanding of what occurred in Boston.
Investigators released photos and video of the two Tsarnaev brothers on Thursday afternoon, but at that point their identities were not known. By late that night Tamerlan was dead.
Mrs Tsarnaeva said her elder son told her by telephone that the FBI had called to inform him that they considered him a suspect and he should come in for questioning.
She said her son refused. “I told them, what do you suspect me of?” she quoted her son as saying. “This is your problem and if you need me you should come to where I am.”
He then told her he was going to drive his younger brother to the university, she said, speaking by telephone from Chechnya.
Mrs Tsarnaeva claimed that her son later called his wife to tell her they were being chased and fired upon.