The top US and Nato commander in Afghanistan said today the coalition depends too much on private-sector contractors.
General Stanley McChrystal, during a four-day visit to France, insisted his forces were keeping close watch on the flow of Taliban fighters who are training in Iran but said the coalition in Afghanistan has become too dependent on private contractors in the effort to stabilise the country.
“I think we’ve gone too far,” McChrystal said at France’s IHEDN military institute. “I actually think we would be better to reduce the number of contractors involved.”
Alternatives could include increasing the number of troops “if necessary,” or “using a greater number of Afghan contractors, or Afghans to help with the mission,” he said.
McChrystal said the use of contractors was founded upon “good intentions,” such as to limit military commitments or to save money for governments.
“I think it doesn’t save money,” he said. “We have created in ourselves a dependency on contractors that I think is greater than it ought to be.”
He didn’t specify where any cuts might come.
A Congressional Research Service report about the Pentagon’s use of contractors in Iraq and Afghanistan said that as of September, more than 11,400 private security contractors were in Afghanistan. It cited Pentagon figures.
The report, published in January and posted on the website of the Federation of American Scientists, said 94% of contractors in Afghanistan were armed – and 90% were local nationals.
The issue of contractors – who carry out tasks as diverse as security for diplomats, advisory roles or mercenary work – has been a thorny one for US and some allied commanders and policymakers.
The company once known as Blackwater was re-dubbed Xe after a deadly shooting incident by its guards that left 17 people dead in Baghdad. Xe is now trying to win US Defence Department approval for a bid to train police in Afghanistan.
McChrystal also pointed to “indications” that some Taliban fighters have had training in Iran, and that weapons and ammunition have come across Iran’s border with Afghanistan.
“The numbers are not operationally significant, they have not changed the fight, and I am not prepared to tell you that the government of Iran is executing that as a policy,” he said.
“But I am prepared to say that we watch it closely, and if something were to increase, it would be something that would concern me significantly,” he said.
Last month, US Defence Secretary Robert Gates accused Iran of “playing a double game” by nurturing relations with the Afghanistan government while supporting insurgents to undermine US and Nato troops. Iran denies the allegation.
A type of Iranian explosive device used heavily by Shiite militias in Iraq - known as explosively formed projectiles – have not turned up in Afghanistan in large numbers.
In the past, Iran’s Shiite republic has been hostile to the Taliban, who adhere to and preach a hardline Sunni form of Islam. Tehran didn’t oppose the US-led ouster of the Taliban from power in Afghanistan in 2001.
Iran has recently warmed to the Afghan government of President Hamid Karzai. Iranian President Mahmoud Ahmadinejad used a visit to Kabul last month to criticise the United States.