Doctors seek protection in French coma patient feud
The case took a surprising turn as doctors refrained from taking a decision on his fate, citing security fears.
Vincent Lambert was left comatose in a 2008 car accident. His wife wants doctors to stop care but his parents disagree and the dispute has riveted France and divided citizens.
The family members had met with the medical team at a Reims hospital expecting to learn whether life support would be ended. Instead, the team said the case will now be referred to the prosecutor’s office to designate a legal representative to protect Lambert.
Lambert’s father, Pierre, told journalists that his son’s doctor had mentioned “a kidnap plot”, but said she wouldn’t go into details.
Pro-life activists have called for Lambert or members of his medical team to be kidnapped in a blog circulating online.
The case has already gone through French courts and in June, Europe’s human rights court ruled that doctors could stop treatment.
Some of the relatives said threats were behind the doctors’ decision Thursday.
“I am profoundly sad and shocked that some people are putting pressure on the hospital, a place that should be intimate,” Lambert’s wife Rachel told the press, bursting into tears.
Francois Lambert, the nephew of Vincent who is also opposed to continued care, said after the meeting that “the intimidation is working. The threats are working.”
The case has pitted Lambert’s wife Rachel and six of his siblings -- who insist the 38-year-old former psychiatric nurse would never have wanted to be kept alive artificially -- against his devout Catholic parents in a bitter legal tug-of-war.
Rachel said she was “shocked” by the decision.
“I am totally confused. The European court and the State Council gave their rulings and I was hoping for an end to this judicial process,” said his sobbing wife.
Vincent’s mother Viviane - who believes her son would improve with better care - said she was “relieved.”
“It means they recognise that he is alive because they want to protect him,” she said.
Euthanasia — which involves an act to kill the patient — is not legal in France. But end-of-life legislation allows doctors to stop treatments in certain cases, following a complex process that includes consultation with family members.
The Lambert case had echoes of the legal fight over Terri Schiavo, a Florida woman who suffered brain damage in 1990 when her heart stopped, and she entered what doctors refer to as a “persistent vegetative state,” or prolonged coma. She died in 2005 after her husband won a protracted court case with Schiavo’s parents to have her feeding tube removed.




